crogers271
crogers271
About
- Username
- crogers271
- Joined
- Visits
- 8,532
- Last Active
Comments
-
I guess to start, was there something the thread you made a month ago that didn't answer this? Because I don't think anything really changed.
The big answers
1: It's not just about survivor strength, but not having enough variety and interesting things to do. Being strong is helpful for the role that needs players, sure, but its not the only thing. The one 'addition' this go around really doesn't add anything and, in many ways, subtracts.
2: Killer is far more interesting for many, with the ability to play different killers and with a friend.
3: Play while you wait means that duos, the most common form of SWF, can move over to playing killer as well.
4: When you take all of that and factor in the need for 80% survivors, 20% killers, the problem magnifies.
I really think it’s the lack of SBMM in 2v8 that is killing it.That could play a role, though with 8 survivors the chance that a survivor is really bad / throwing is just generally higher than in 1v4. But I don't know of anyone who regularly praises the quality of survivors they are paired with in soloq in 1v4 so that doesn't seem like the reason.
My experiences have been up and down. The last two trials all the survivors were focused and doing objectives and we steam rolled through, but on Friday I hit a stretch where it seemed like those on my team didn't know how to play the play game.
I fully realize that 2v8 is supposed to be a casual, fun mode and not supposed to be hyper-competitive with fully accurate SBMM.The reason SBMM isn't accurate has nothing to do with the mode per se, but with the way queues are they don't want to make them any longer.
I do think a general problem is BHVR's attitude which is encapsulated by your sentence - viewing it as a fun, casual mode. I, the people I've played with, the comments I've seen in chat, don't seem to take it any more or less seriously than 1v4. It's a substantially different game, and whether you like it more or less is completely subjective, but BHVR's attitude towards it doesn't seem to mirror the player base which might be a problem in making longer term improvements.
But that's straying off topic.
Is there anything that can be done to fix 2v8 to incentivize veteran players to play despite the bad teammate frustrations? I guess killer side could be nerfed even more to make killer side super frustrating to play and deter people from queueing up as killer, but I’d much rather have something to incentivize people to choose survivor role instead.I think they just have to keep improving the mode while being careful not to drive away those who like it.
1: Create subclasses. As an example create a variety of the Guides, one with repressed alliance, one with built to last (if they keep the items), etc. Obviously these wouldn't be 1 to 1 conversions of 1v4 perks to 2v8, but the general idea. Give survivors more ways to do the classes.
2: Adjust the way the catch up mechanic works. Give a slight decrease to the progression gained per hook state, but then also make it so deaths reduce the rate at which gens regress (or how many times killers can regress). 2v8 keeps one of the core 1v4 problems, if the killers get out a couple of survivors early the game is effectively finished, but survivors are 'stuck' in the game playing a pointless trial. I think its those really 'bad' game, not just where the survivors lose but its an incredibly boring loss, that makes survivors exit after the game instead of playing another.
-
@cogsturning said:
It's wild that all it took were the recent few months of CCs and their parroting drones to get StB nerfed but ten years of complaints about tunneling and it's getting multiple buffs after some preformative bit of canceled faux hope.
Yeah, I'd like to hear the justification for disabling it on every survivor after a use. That's a forum/CC complaint that's illogical and really makes it seem like BHVR is listening to certain voices verbatim. The 'swapping hook stages around' never made any sense, and if the killer continues to target one survivor again and again to the point that more than one survivor gets to use StB, well good. It's supposed to punish exactly that type of play.
What's interesting is that maybe the best complaint about StB, that a killer who isn't tunneling, but is at 2/1/1 on the hooks can suddenly be 1/1/1/1, isn't changed at all.
-
@Your_Dad_Playing_DbD said:
I play both sides about equally and I’d be fine with some sort of anti-tunnel/anti-camp mechanic, but I have yet to see anything that isn’t overly punishing for killers when they tunnel or camp for legit reason (people who claim you never have to do it are just not being honest or they simply don’t play killer at all). If anyone has any good ideas that aren’t overly-punishing / abusable like the first version that was tried, I’m willing to listen.
There were lots of ideas. The starting problem with how they approached it is that they threw everything at the wall. They called it a Quality of Life when it was a radical, unexpected overhaul of how the game would work on both sides. Even those of us who were extremely anti-tunnel were surprised by the overall changes. Most people believed, even those who really liked the ideas, that there were going to have to be some substantial changes to the original numbers.
If instead of that they focused on one of those choices and seeing if that changed things before going more radical it would have been a lot healthier to get feedback. @Aven_Fallen mentioned it and I and others have discussed it as well, but also just adjusting the amount of gen speed increase that happens after the first survivor dies based on total hooks would have been a healthy way forward as well.
With three genning, players going next, and hook camping they had a pretty clear problem, and it took them too long to make some pretty obvious changes to improve those elements without radically altering the game. Why they totally lost their focus on what worked I have no idea. They could easily though make a similar change to tunneling by giving a large boost to gens if there was a death at 3 hooks - it would deal with what is considered the most problematic form of tunneling and the chance that it would impact games outside of that would be extremely minimal.
-
@NeverSolus said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4117234#Comment_4117234
… what?
A killer chasing a survivor around a loop is "forcing" the killer to stay in the same place. How is that fun or engaging design? This logic doesn't work in the present game as it is. Most perks do things of this nature. Doing gens "Forces" a survivor to stay in one place. There's a great deal of things that "force" players to stay in a given place or loop to achieve a counter-action. That's… that's literally the purpose of looping.
Are you suggesting that looping is inherently unfun design? Because I'll agree, don't make me do it. I hate looping.I find it interesting that we're about a year away form BHVR cancelling anti-tunnel on the grounds of 'forcing players on rails'. Which, fair enough, that isn't great gameplay, but then using the opposite logic on survivor play.
-
Don't put yourself in a corner once you know its Wraith and keep a look out for him. Even if he does get you caught, its just one hit.
Nemesis zombies are annoying. Slowly leading away a slow AI controlled creature isn't thrilling gameplay, but he's certainly not a balance issue.
Slinger? He might be the weakest 2v8 killer.
Wesker is fine.
Plague's hypothetical issue is much the same as legions, pairing with another killer removes the downside of being a Plague.
-
In 2v8 - it's pretty bad. As a random item you have no way to plan around it. If the plan is to get one and then engage the killers in chase, you might waste a lot of time looking for one.
Even when you do activate it, there's a lot of possibilities that make it bad
A: You are better at chase than the killer and don't need it (in my experience, the killers who commit to these chases I probably didn't need the added haste to loop)
B: You get double teamed, making it ineffective
C: The killer sees how fast you are moving and just goes to another survivor
D: You just end up doing gens/healing
So it is a guaranteed loss of time (which might get interrupted) for a benefit that might not even be useful.
For 1v4 - I think Invocation's have to be permanent benefits - given the risks associated with going to the basement, the time commitment (leaving the others in a 3v1), and then permanent broken status, the tradeoff has to be pretty substantial to justify those costs.
Now the issue with it being a haste boost in 1v4 is that haste is a lot stronger in 1v4 (somewhat killer dependent). So any type of permanent haste boost would likely be too strong, any type of temporary one likely too weak.
-
@NeverSolus said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4116655#Comment_4116655
Arguably @ForTheEntity is entirely in his rights here. Esa just outright entered the thread straw maning and insulting people. No one owes anyone a response. Like you said, no one forces anyone to engage, but if we're going to, they should be actual responses contributing to a sensible, mature discussion of the topic at hand. Not a 'Lol your opinion is invalid.'
Calling For the Entity out for this behavior when he's responding with the energy he's receiving is not sensible.Esa just outright entered the thread straw maning and insulting people.In this thread, where?
The first post is a pretty straightforward forum style question - what if this rule applied to the other side? There's a couple of responses that I imagine could be made to that, but its a pretty logical question to bring up. @Arcturus brings up the idea its a valid point.
The second post is responding after being called a troll and reiterates the previous point
The third post Esaraf is far more confrontational (though this is in response to twice being called a troll), but he lists a number of reasons for why Nurse is a problem (3), which is in response to being told: "They can't actually come up with a good argument as to why the Nurse is actually a mad dog killer who is problematic in DbD."
In this thread, none of that seems to be straw manning and the insults come after they were already started.
-
@ForTheEntity said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4116640#Comment_4116640
It's pretty well established that DbD cannot be balanced around comp where you have players who are in the top 0.01% of the skill bracket and there are Nurse's who can blink with pixel-perfect accuracy. How many Nurses do you encounter that are that good in public matches?
Tier lists are generally based on potential. In the right hands the Nurse has the potential to be S-tier. But in most players' hands who miss a few blinks they quickly find gens getting done and gates getting opened and that's why she has a kill rate <50%. That's why BHVR keeps leaving her where she is despite continuous whining from the community and her continued placement at the top of tier lists. Tier lists are opinions, unlike the stats.
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4116646#Comment_4116646
Nice try. You just hate Nurse and appear unable to apply logic in a discussion about her.
Nice try. You just hate Nurse and appear unable to apply logic in a discussion about her.No one forces you to engage with people on the forum if you don't think its worth your time, but if you're going to respond to someone it should actually include some type of response and not just avoid what they typed.
-
I'm in the 'rework' camp, though I'd give blindness for her a try as well, because I think she's a flawed design:
1: She's absolutely awful to start off, and way too strong once mastered. Neither of those are very interesting games.
2: Skill expression is too much on her, not enough on the survivors.
3: Being her design violates other basic concepts of the game, cool perk ideas have to be thrown out because 'what about Nurse?'
@esarraf said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4116561#Comment_4116561
Hey real quick, let's say they released a survivor perk that was a little hard to use but after a few hours anyone can realistically use it and when you do you automatically win the game. Because that's what you are saying classifies as balanced right now.
We have a few perks that demonstrate your point that got nerfed, and they weren't even autowins. DS people argue can't be 5 seconds because that would be way too powerful, but starting survivors can't even reliably hit the skill check. Old MFT, 3% for most survivors who aren't looping experts wasn't really that big of a deal and not worth just staying injured.
Probably the closest autowin that definitely got nerfed would be the old, old BNPs with continuous skill checks.
-
having both killers the same character would have made power management a little bit easier as they could both use their props (Trapper traps, Xeno tunnels etcIn the long run that seems more difficult to balance - do you balance around the idea of one killer having access, or both?
I think it might also create engine problems on where do you spawn everything.
There's also a theme feel. Two Aliens would make perfect sense, but two Weskers?
Basically - for some killers I think it would work power and theme wise, for others I think it fails one or the other. I wouldn't have a problem putting it in for only some killers, but I think BHVR would view it as an all or nothing issue.
-
but apparently they can detect if you intentionally die on hook ?They actually can't and the systems they've tried to put in place have demonstrated that pretty well.
-
Outside of it being a streamer whose videos you can watch, I think its generally just a guess. Frequently it feels like 'I lost, most be a SWF' type of deal. Something like all similar names is pretty close, same outfits maybe but I've done that in soloq as well.
There's definitely things that happen that make it more likely, but lots of time randoms also just play well.
@shalo said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4116095#Comment_4116095
What are the other 48%?
32% 2 person SWF, 16% 3 person SWF.
-
@ThatRyanB said:
Thanks for the feedback here, folks! I'm happy to pass along your feedback about the time requirement on this being a point of friction. That aside, though, is the effect something you find interesting or valuable?
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4116011#Comment_4116011
You're correct. Survivors that complete the circle will receive its effects.
I have yet to actually activate one of these after 15 2v8s, but they certainly are causing lots of thrown matches as the other survivors search chest after chest to set one up.
Edit to add: well saying the above apparently was enough to actually make it happen, though both times I did it when it wasn't really important. Once I was on death hook and just found one already set up, as I was trying to not get tunneled went ahead and did it. Second one I found one in a chest, set it up way out of the way, and after all the gens were done I went back and did it just for progress on the quest.
-
@HoodedWildKard said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4114389#Comment_4114389
This is why i made the thread to spitball ideas to make hard tunneling unviable. Could've worded the title better I suppose.
Well you're now past four hundred comments, a few of which were even on topic, so I think the title did its job.
-
5v5 was one of the modes I was most interested in as well.
In case nobody was aware, way back before the first iterations of game modes, the survey had asked what we wanted, which is why we got 2v8, chaos shuffle and lights out.So I think 2v8 and chaos shuffle were already locked in barring a massive negative result from the survey. I think the survey was more for general interest in futures modes. I do remember at the time thinking, and I believe BHVR saying, that these modes were just the start, I never would have guessed we'd still be cycling through them (especially with one being basically dead).
The only other question I'd have is how teams would interact with each other, if at all. Would they be physically in the map, having to weigh wasting resources to sabotage the other team or would they be more along the lines of ghosting, where you can see where the enemy team is but can't interact in a meaningful way. Maybe even score based on resources used compared to the other team?From what I recall of their explanation (which was brief) - it was going to be a game of gen control (which I suspect would have meant the match would have a timer). So if team A is on a gen for 15 seconds, that's their gen unless team B can be on it for 15 seconds as well. I think they also said survivors could ping opponents for their killer. So everyone would be on the same map fighting over the same gens, but, at least from what they said it would have been a very different game.
What I thought it was going to be, and would still like, and this king of goes with what @cogsturning brought up, is if you took a map like Dead Dawg, mirrored it, and connected them. Both teams start on one map and attack the other, goal is to get the most of your team 'out'. So survivors are primarily attackers, killers primarily defenders, but also have options for killers to defend against the other killer if he crosses over and options for survivors to fall back to defend by undoing progress / tagging enemies.
-
@Hopi said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4115667#Comment_4115667
You can expect a killer to play 'fair' (as in, don't tunnel, slug, camp), but you cannot go into end-game chat if they did it anyway (for whatever reason) and berate them for it. You cannot demand from the killer that they should have played 'fair'. If they choose to tunnel, slug or camp, then that's well within their right. The game allows it after all.
You can also expect Survivors to not behave toxic towards the killer by using Head-on, flashbangs, t-bagging constantly, but you cannot demand that they won't. You cannot go into end-game chat and demand that they won't do it again. The game allows it, so they are well within their right to do it.
And in my particular case, you can expect a killer player not to play as a certain character (in my case, Judgment), because some players consider her to be OP, but you cannot demand it.
I got berated multiple times in end-game chat for my playstyle (random-aura build) and that I only won because was I was playing a 'broken' killer and that they would have won if it was any other killer. Survivor-players do not get to demand from killer-players which killer they play, or how they play. They do not get to demand that I play anything other than Judgment.
It sounds more like your issue is not expectations vs demands, but don't be rude in end game chat.
-
@Mandy said:
aahhhh the forum has received an update…thanks for letting me know that changed as well, I'll go and see what I can do to re-adjust it.
While you're looking at the forum update changes, the edit tag also doesn't seem to appear on posts anymore.
-
@Hopi said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4115575#Comment_4115575
Why is it not a entitlement/unwritten rule to expect people not to suicide?
Because players can play the game anyway the want, within the confines of what the game allows. Anyone, including myself, can have (and most certainly has) certain expectations about other players, that is absolutely true. But you cannot have guarantees from anyone.
So if a survivor decides to kills themself on hook (and by that I mean when it's early in the game, they're on their first hook and they brought a perk/offering that allows for a chance to self unhook), there's nothing anyone can do to dissuade them of doing so, because the game allows it.
It's an absolute ######### move towards your team, because you're basically abandoning your team early on, but they can still do it if they choose to.
For every trial, I have only one expectation (not a demand) for the other players and that is that they want to play the match through until the end (why would you queue otherwise?) and that they do their best, regardless of how much that is. But I'm certainly not allowed to actually demand all of that, or anything else. From any player.
And that's the point I'm trying to make here: When playing Dead by Daylight, or any multiplayer PvP game for that matter, you cannot demand any behaviors, results, or outcomes from the others players.
Expectations, sure. But demands, no. Absolutely not.
And I started this whole topic because survivor players that I've encountered in the last 10 days while playing Judgment demanded certain behaviors from me. Certain outcomes. And if I choose not to provide those, that's totally fine, because every player can play the game how they want, within the confines of what the game allows.
And on a side-note: There is a difference between sabotaging your own team for selfish reasons at the start of the trial, and bringing certain perks or using a certain playstyle. And although both are allowed, if you have to complain, I'd probably complain about the former.
Expectations, sure. But demands, no. Absolutely not.What's your line between an expectation and a demand?
-
Quoting from two different replies:
But it's not as if there are unwritten rules that dictate that players should or should not play a certain way. That's the argument I'm trying to make.and
No player, survivor or killer, should throw a tantrum because they don't like we way things are going.Why is it not a entitlement/unwritten rule to expect people not to suicide?
BHVR has a an 'anti-go' next system, if a player doesn't trigger it, what's the problem?
If we're using BHVR has our arbiter, they've said multiple times that people can play the game, broadly, how they want. Want to play for pips? Hide for hatch? Never touch a gen? As long as they fit within the broad rules BHVR has laid out, aren't you asking for your own 'unwritten' rule on how people behave?
-
@tjt85 said:
Most of the ones I really hated got changes (Franklin's, Knock Out and Sloppy Butcher), so there aren't really many left in isolation that I hate anymore. Just the ones that are a middle finger to SoloQ like Hex: The Third Seal and No Quarter. I guess the ones that buff SWF would be annoying too if I ever saw them in my Killer games (things like We're Gonna Live Forever, Background Player and Shoulder The Burden), but I don't really.
I don't usually see any of these perks in most of my games, so I can't say if they desperately need changes.
I also kinda hate Hex perks in general, just because of their inconsistency and the play styles and perk combos that revolve around defending them. And also because I feel like I have the worst luck with them since they tend to stay up all game if I'm playing Survivor or get cleansed immediately whenever I'm playing Killer. I wonder if Killer players would trade being able to see their hex totems for much better hidden spawn locations.
This is basically how I was going to answer the question. So I'm just going to go with what tjt85 said.
-
@Carth said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4114709#Comment_4114709
If it was the furthest 2 statues, then just like PH. Caging/exiling 90% of the time would be a bad play to do. Any regular PH players do not cage on demand for that exact reason just like no Judgement player exiles 2+ players simulteanously for the exact same reason. It's killing your own pressure and macro play.
Zealous is not worth: exile → 2 seconds later unhook. Just like for PH, caging when you are not in a great position is a misplay because most of the time it's just a free unhook for the survivor team
Pyramidhead there though sounds like a good mechanic. Players should be faced with decisions of 'do I use this or not?' Just 'use this, always' seems like a bad design.
-
specifically how frustrating it is that matches can fly by in literally 4 minutes.1: Killers can also end the matches really quickly. I'm not sure why you are just focused on the survivor possibility. People have proposed comeback/slowdown mechanics on both sides before that would prevent the extreme speedruns.
2: I think this is an intentional design decision by BHVR. While they've nerfed a lot of things on the survivor side, gen rush isn't getting touched, its actually been enhanced with new perks over the past few years. So you're proposing a change for something that the player base (or at least BHVR's perception of the players) doesn't really want changed.
The Core Loop Stays the Same:Survivors do gens exactly like normal. However, even if all 5 gens are slammed out in 4 minutes, the gates are locked until the clock hits the 10-minute mark.The Endurance Test:If survivors finish gens early, their reward is that their objective is done. The rest of the match becomes a pure endurance test—looping, hiding, and outsmarting the killer until time runs out.
To be upfront, that sounds really boring. One of the most hated times from killers is just the survivors hiding out, slowly walking around rocks. For the survivors - if you had four survivors, one of them gets in chase, the other three just stand around doing nothing.
And 'nothing to do' seems like a pretty bad idea for a video game.
The Hatch/Early Ends Stay Untouched:If a killer dominates and wipes out a team in 5 minutes, the match ends immediately. No waiting around. If 3 survivors die early, the timer shuts off, the Hatch spawns, and it plays out exactly like the current live game.
As mentioned above, I don't understand why one is fine and worth preserving and the other has to be made impossible. Without having to worry about slowdown the chance of killers just stomping survivors goes up rather substantially.
Endgame Perks:Perks like NOED, Blood Warden, or Remember Me would automatically light up during the final 3-4 minutes of the match or right at the 0:00 mark, ensuring endgame builds don't lose their value.
and
Killers can finally drop Pop or Pain Res and run fun chase or info builds because they know they have guaranteed time to play.This just seems like massive killer buffs. The strongest survivor build is practically useless, killer's are now stronger by not having to worry about gen protection, and killers are guaranteed that they can run an end game build and when it would trigger (automatic noed? guaranteed Blood Warden?)
An have been playing for years an this was something I realized an dont know if it was talked about.There's people who have discussed it quite a bit. Either from just nixing some of the stronger gen run options to a larger 'slowdown / comeback mechanic idea'. There tends to be three problems
1: Some people like the faster paced trials
2: Some people like variability. Maybe one trial will be six minutes, the next fourteen, the one after than nine. It gives each trial a different feel while a standard time would become repetitive.
3: Lots of people seem to hate enforced mechanics. Players want to engage in actions that advance their objective. Just 'wait it out' isn't very engaging (see version 2 of BHVR's Deathgarden for a good example)
-
Topic: it's impossible to actually stop it from happening, BHVR has said repeatedly they are okay with it if not outright supportive, a hypothetical about what the game would be like with no communication is cool to think about and all, but its not possible that would ever be implemented.
@Aven_Fallen said:
2026 and people still think that Voice Chat is cheating.
Even IF the Devs would do something that things like Discord or Teamspeak are detected and people would not use it, what do you think will happen? All the casual SWFs will just quit. They want to play and chat with their friends, BHVR would make that impossible, so they would have no reason to play DBD.
Meanwhile, sweaty SWFs would keep playing, because they would go out of their way to have communication (e.g. using their phones). Great Job, you now really only have sweaty SWFs and also killed a large portion of the playerbase.
Let alone that Consoles have built-in voicechat, which BHVR would not be able to do anything about.
EDIT:
Let alone that all of your Discussions are about Discord and they start back in 2022 (!!). At some point, you really need to stop and accept that you are wrong.https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/349370/swf-and-discord
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/361871/3nd-party-softwares
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/362852/unfair-play
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/365805/behaviour-allows-cheat-in-game
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/381375/do-you-think-discord-swf-unfair
Maybe just a few more posts will change people's minds.
Meanwhile, sweaty SWFs would keep playing, because they would go out of their way to have communication (e.g. using their phones).Ah, back to the 90s/2000s for gaming.
-
@Elan said:
If you get matched with people of your level every game then yes, it may be survivor sided in mid mmr too. But fact that many people bring newer players and those always magnet the killers attention they mostly end up being the reason you lost. One bad survivor and game over.
But fact that many people bring newer players and those always magnet the killers attention they mostly end up being the reason you lost. One bad survivor and game over.This is true, but its much bigger than just one new player. Survivors are only as strong as their weakest link and, even if there was a great matchmaker, it's very likely there will be a weak link. Not just will one survivor inevitably be the 'weakest' of the group, but factor in things like every survivor having killers they are better or worse against or that someone might just be having a bad game and playing well below their level.
And that's the game. Survivors are only as strong as their weakest link, but for the purpose of talking about which sided the game is, the chance of four survivors being equally strong (again, even if there was a perfect matchmaker) is extremely low, so we shouldn't base game discussions around that extreme outlier.
-
I'm not exactly sure what you mean.
If by random we mean that it could be as strange as the main building appearing along a side wall or right in the middle, that's both likely technically difficult as well as way too impactful.
If by random we mean choosing from a few different possible setups, that just seems like we are bringing back multiple map versions. There's only so many configurations you could have of a many main buildings, so you'd pretty quickly get 'Badham, Main building type C' or something. That seems to go against the idea of map bloat.
Overall, unless I misunderstand the idea, it doesn't seem feasible without it being way too impactful on the overall match depending on how the spawn occurs, or returning to just having multiple versions of each map.
-
@BloodBehemoth said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4114310#Comment_4114310
No, that would be according to every comp-level tournament where they ban a TON of survivor perks and tactics and killers still don't stand a chance.
In addition to what @FerrousFacade said:
1: The biggest restriction on killer is that they don't just get to play Nurse every trial. Yes, if survivors bring the best possible builds, and the killer doesn't, that would be a mismatch. But it shouldn't be surprise that an S tier survivor loadout would destroy a C tier killer setup.
2: Survivors (in most comp leagues) know the killer they are going to play on. If pub games let survivors know the killer they were going to face (and let them change their build) escape rates would skyrocket.
3: Killers do really well. I haven't watched season XI of DbDLeague, but looking back to the Winter Circuit tournament, going into the Grand Final they average 2.88 kills per game (72% KR) and 43.62% of the games ended in a 4k (these stats are visible at the beginning of the video for the Grand Final).
-
@Your_Dad_Playing_DbD said:
Everyone is going to have a different view of this based on their personal experience. If you’re consistently doing that well in your killer games, then yeah you’re going to think the game is very killer-sided. By the way, kudos to you for doing that well as a low-tier killer. Also kudos to you for backing up your opinion with your actual stats - a lot of people who claim the game is survivor/killer-sided never do that.
BHVR has to balance the game based on the full population stats and not just loud individual voices. The 60% target kill rate seems to be the sweet spot where killer and survivors queues are the most balanced. I remember super long survivor queue times during peak evening hours when the killer rates were lower. Now the wait to play survivor in the evenings is much more reasonable. I did notice that killer queue times were much longer than normal during the recent new killer releases and special events, but in the past few days the killer queue times seem to be back to normal as well.The 60% target kill rate seems to be the sweet spot where killer and survivors queues are the most balanced.Saying the game needs to be killer-sided to make a better game / keep reasonable queues / maintain the theme / etc. is one thing, just as long as its not the starting point on whether the game is killer or survivor sided.
-
@cogsturning said:
I like that no matter how many nerfs survivor gets the game will eternally be survivor-sided to some people. Multiple survivor meta perks got the hammer and the 5s BT cut has made tunneling go back to being super easy. They could make it so survivors can only walk for 10s after getting off a gen and this crew will just be like, "You just have to prewalk to a pallet skill issue" while continuing to cite an invisible number they make assumptions about as defense.
That's a good a point and an evergreen thing. 'Broken' perks gets blamed for survivors being too strong, sometimes those perks are annihilated, and the talking point doesn't change.
To contrast that with killers, no one disagrees that Skull Merchant is down in the basement. If a killer gets nerfed, survivors don't seem to dispute that quite as much.
-
@radiantHero23 said:
Does mmr take loadout into account now?
If not, then what "tier" the killer, your playing as, should not make a difference, right?
The only thing I could see being the case is you playing more lower tier killers, resulting in you getting better at playing them, resulting in you winning more as lower tier killers, resulting in your mmr on these killers being higher than on higher tier killers that you play less often.
(that was an atrocious sentence. I'm sorry)
The only thing I could see being the case is you playing more lower tier killers,It's one of those without gameplay and a large sample size kind of hard to say anything definitively, but could just be the same level of survivor strength, but against a strong killer they feel weak, against a weak killer they feel strong.
-
@Smoe said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4113892#Comment_4113892
Going off of wikipedia specifically, there's not nearly as much work for hire jobs that they've done after DBD was released, compared to before.
It still is their safety net in case their own games don't do well, however they're not nearly as reliant on it compared to before.
My only issue with the wikipedia list is that there are games on BHVR's site that don't appear anywhere on wiki, so I'm not sure how each list got put together. A lot of more recent games that BHVR says they were part of our missing from wikipedia. Maybe there's just a difference in terminology.
however they're not nearly as reliant on it compared to before.That part I think is absolutely true.
-
As Smoe mentioned, this is something BHVR does. You can see a list of 'partner' games on their website. There's everything from Mortal Kombat, to Civilization 7, to Farcry 5 - a whole bunch of different styles of game.
Does it increase the chance of licensing? No idea.
@Smoe said:
It's just a work for hire job bhvr did, something they almost exclusively did back in the day, and still does every now and then these days.
Same way that games like Until Dawn, The Quarry and The Casting of Frank Stone are all work for hire jobs done by Supermassive games.
It's just a work for hire job bhvr did, something they almost exclusively did back in the day, and still does every now and then these days.To my understanding it's not just an every now and then thing, but still a pretty huge part of their business model. Though they don't release public info that frequently so I might have missed something.
-
It more should be its own perk/condition, like Finesse. But if exhaustion could be recovered by running, that would be a bad idea, and takes out way too much of gameplay revolved around managing exhaustion mechanics.
Now I'd actually have exhaustion recover at like 1% while running because I think 99ing an exhaustion perk is more cheesy than skill, but that's a separate topic.
-
@Aven_Fallen said:
Yeah, it all makes no sense. Either Vigil should apply to multiple status effects or it should only apply to Exhaustion, but with a bigger value (even more than 40%). IMO Exhaustion does not even matter that much, considering that it does not go down while running and it rarely happens that Killers abandon a chase.
But first nerfing it and then slapping another Double-Nerf on it… I really dont understand it. I get their reasoning that they dont want to have to keep Vigil in mind whenever they want to do something with Status Effects. I think this is reasonable, even tho I dont think that they will do the other aspect which comes with it and status effects have a lower duration (because if they made them longer to not have them be too weak against Vigil and then they remove Vigil, there is no justification to make them longer).
However, Vigil will be worse than on Release, since 20% on a few status effects (including Exhaustion) was better than 30% on just Exhaustion. (And obviously they buffed the Range, but I dont really count that since people bring Vigil mainly for themselves)
But first nerfing it and then slapping another Double-Nerf on it… I really dont understand it.It's really hard to look at what they're doing and have BHVR come off favorably.
Either it is was so overpowered and broken, thus necessitating the massive nerf, that they massively dropped the ball by not touching it for so long.
Or it wasn't that overpowered, in which case the level of nerf that it took just seems non-sensical.
It doesn't help that the given reasoning - that it interferes with too many other game elements, makes sense for part of the nerf, but doesn't in anyway explain why the other part was also nerfed.
-
@cogsturning said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4113339#Comment_4113339
What an absurd statement. This role bias mentality is what taints the feedback and ruins the game. If you're good at killer you should be put with good survivors and both sides should be able to win. Why would anyone become good at survivor and play the role if they're destined to Iose against a killer that put in the same amount of time and effort?
It reminds me of the line I was once heard - many killers think they are so good at the game that they'll only believe its balanced when they go 50/50 with the best team in the world.
-
The fowl perks and items that survivors can use to generally make this game unplayable is why swf are hated among the killer communityThis doesn't really have anything to do with tunneling, which SWFs have the easiest time countering. Also its not really unique to one side, sweatiness goes both ways and either is integral to the game or one of its biggest shortcomings, depending on your point of view.
Also, @GentlemanFridge the above quoted sentence immediately made me think of you.
Using strong toolboxes to make it impossible for killer to hook, especially when the killer deserves the hook from playing well.Why does the killer deserve the hook? Survivors don't deserve a gen just because they got a lot of progress on it and then hit with a regression.
It's also really difficult to make it 'impossible to hook'. More difficult, sure, but if hooking was always guaranteed and there was no possible interactivity, that would be pretty boring.
Using perks likePower Struggleto make it impossible for killers to pick up from a pallet.What does that have to do with tunneling? If a SWF is running this they can use it whether the killer is tunneling or not. And like the above post, if pickups where always safe less interactivity would make for a boring game.
One game a chill team and the next is a fully meta (Powerful perks) swf. Killers simply can't take a chanceAnd survivors don't know whether they'll be hitting a chill killer or a sweaty Nurse.
One more thing to consider before hating the way killers play, in a 4 man swf it is basically 16 perks vs 4 perks.Things can't be compared in isolation. Make gens take 30 seconds and survivors would dominate with zero perks, make them take three minutes and the killer wouldn't need any.
-
As @pidgeon mentioned, its no secret why people tunnel anymore than why they gen rush. It's a highly effective strategy while also being incredibly straightforward, but its not very healthy for the game.
-
@ForTheEntity said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4113180#Comment_4113180
At no point did he call the Survivor Rulebook equal to the Killer Rulebook or that tunneling was equal to gen rushing.
There is no false equivalence in the post that he made on August 5th. Let it rest.
They literally says both have no meaning, I just quoted it.
Here is the quote on tunneling/gen rush:
You can't tell me not to tunnel just as I can't tell you not to gen rush.There is no false equivalence in the post that he made on August 5thThe discussion was going well before that, I can't go back and quote every post all the time. My response comes after quite a few back and forths, for example from July 29th post that started this chain of the thread -
No more genrushing, if you finish a generator before the killer has at least 2 hooks, stop and let them get those 2 hooks. It's only fair. 2 hooks per generator. Those are the new rules, and in return we promise not to tunnel.Proposing a bad rule as justification for why another rule shouldn't exist is a false equivalence (because the substance isn't that rules shouldn't exist, but the merit of the rule). The underlying fallacy became more evident over the discussion.
Let it rest.I'm not the one who revives the thread after a its been dormant for awhile. If a thread hasn't been touched in a day I let it go, but otherwise when someone responds to me if I have something to add, I do. It's a discussion forum after all.
-
@Firellius said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4113259#Comment_4113259
Distortion was nerfed purely becouse people using it were ratting and barely interacting with both their teammates and killer players.
A few problems with that theory.
- 'Ratting' was not the complaint that got Distortion into the crosshairs. The initial pushback against the perk was specifically about its ability to thwart some of the new, powercrept aura perks killers had. For the longest time, BBQ & Chili used to be the primary source of aura reading for killers, with the perk itself specifically being designed to give the killer direction, but not give them a free chase. Nowhere To Hide blew that off its hinges and just gave killers immediate access to chases, on demand. Floods of Rage and Weave Attunement similarly gave killers direct access to chase, rather than just direction. Distortion levelled the playing field back to what it was prior to the intel power-creep, and thus garnered backlash.
- 'Ratting' was not a Distortion problem. The only thing Distortion changed about ratting is, specifically, that it allowed people to stay hidden while doing gens, healing, cleansing hexes and whatever else. Without Distortion, hiding is only possible via lockers, which does force non-interaction.
- The nerf to Distortion was not aimed at 'Ratting', but instead at the original complaint about forcing killers to look for survivors with their own eyes again. If ratting had been the issue, Distortion's recharge could've been tied to conspicuous actions like gen repair, healing, unhooking and hex-cleansing. But it wasn't, it was tied to chases.
Two things I'll add onto these solid points
1: The distortion nerf happened well before the update to crows. It was extremely easy to reset the Crow the timer, meaning there was next to no need for distortion.
2: Even if a rat was going to use distortion, one token is more than enough for an emergency. In the old system the rat was going to avoid any in progress gen, be in a locker for BBQ, not engage with an any element that could reveal there aura. Even 1 token is enough of an emergency backup if a player's intent was truly just to rat. It's the player who is actually engaged in the game who has reason to need the more tokens.
-
@MDRSan said:
No need to change Judgement really. This could be fixed by having survivor perks activate on gaining a hook state rather than being hooked. (I don’t want to hear about Shoulder as something that would break that. If someone wants to give themselves a hook state just to activate Dead Hard or Decisive Strike - fine, who cares?)
Killer perks aren’t as big of a deal comparatively since they can always choose to hook vs. exile/cage if they want to activate associated effects. Scourge hooks would still need to be scourge hooks - there’s not really anything that can be done about that.
Um, everyone's trying to have good rage fight and you're just coming in here with some common sense proposals?
-
@AbsolutGrndZer0 said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4111729#Comment_4111729
Never said all rules were wrong, which is why your analogies were and still are bad. But, unless BHVR makes it a rule, the survivor rulebook nor the killer rulebook have any meaning. Is tunneling wrong? Nope. Is it something many survivor players find unfair? Yes. But it is not wrong and it's not against the rules. Robbing banks, that's against the law. Tunneling is not.
Never said all rules were wrong, which is why your analogies were and still are bad.I'll just quote you: "The Survivor Rulebook has no meaning, the Killer Rulebook has no meaning. Play how you want. You can't tell me not to tunnel just as I can't tell you not to gen rush. It's all absurd."
Note - It's all absurd.
I then went and explained why that was a false equivalence. You misunderstand that the examples were an explanation of what a false equivalence is. I'm explaining the logical error you are making and giving you two examples of what that logical error would look like in other scenarios.
But it is not wrong and it's not against the rules. Robbing banks, that's against the law.If robbing banks was not against the law, would it be okay?
-
@Arcturus said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4112522#Comment_4112522
Honestly I still think that for survivors it should count the amount of escapes rather than just if you escaped. I'm not sure but the new system still sounds like if you run the killer for 5 gens then die and the rest of your team gets out you might still lose MMR because all you did was chase and nothing else and you didn't escape. Hopefully however the MMR is calculated it accounts for that but I have no idea
I've said it on a couple of things, but I feel that BHVR frequently tries to reinvent the wheel instead of taking the obvious choice - in this case just factoring in the other survivors.
BHVR really, really doesn't want to officially say survivors are a team. Sure, to have success they have to play as a team, most survivors play it as a team game, they allow SWFs which explicitly act as a team, and their new MMR system rewards actions that ultimately benefit the whole group, but they want keep the idea that each survivor is 'independent'.
All of that would be more easily accomplished and understood by just factoring survivors in as a group without the complexity. They could even maintain 50% is determined solely by the individual results, 50% by the others if they still want it to be individual focused.
Hopefully however the MMR is calculated it accounts for that but I have no ideaAs a hypothetical, it would also depend on what the killer does, but I really doubt the ability of the computer to determine skill on that precise of a level.
-
@KingOfGhost said:
Here is a stronger version that responds directly while keeping the discussion focused on accessibility and balance.
So, in other words, should we exclude players from experiencing a Killer they like simply because they were born with physical limitations? Should we just tell them, “We don’t need to make the game more accessible for you. Just don’t play that Killer and move on”?
I don’t think that should be the answer. If reasonable accessibility options can let more players enjoy a Killer without giving them an unfair gameplay advantage, then those options should be considered.
I understand the argument that the Killer player chooses which Killer they play, while Survivors cannot choose which Killer they face. But I don’t think that means Killer-specific accessibility needs should automatically be considered less important.
Choosing a Killer does not remove the accessibility problem. If someone really enjoys Spirit, for example, but cannot properly use audio cues because of a hearing impairment, telling them to simply play another Killer is not really an accessibility solution. The point of accessibility is to reduce unnecessary barriers so more people can experience the same content.
That also does not mean Spirit should receive perfect visual tracking or anything that gives additional information. A visual audio system could be designed to represent roughly the same information a hearing player already receives, while keeping the same uncertainty and limitations.
And I agree that general Killer accessibility should probably be the priority where possible. Things such as visual sound cues, camera shake reduction, better input options, clearer power UI, contrast settings, FoV options, and customizable visual indicators could benefit many Killers rather than only one.
The FoV option and aura/scratch-mark customization are good examples of progress. I’m not saying Killer players have received nothing. I’m saying there are still areas where accessibility could be expanded.
The mobile visual-audio system is also exactly the kind of feature I think would be worth testing on the main game. It does not necessarily need to be copied directly. Put a version in the Beta tab, test how accurate it is, determine whether it gives too much information, adjust the range and directionality, and collect feedback from both disabled players and the wider playerbase.
That is what the Beta tab seems perfect for.
The goal shouldn’t be to make a Killer easier to play. It should be to make sure a player is struggling because of the Killer’s intended gameplay difficulty, not because important information is only available through a physical ability they may not have.
Your argument would probably be better than what the AI cooked up as like a lot of AI its pablum without any real depth.
This long post amounts to - 'I want something better, but also not unfair.'
So would everyone. That's a goal, not a process, and doesn't deal with the difficulties of actually doing it.
The issue is that a game (any game that's not 100% chance) needs to have some form of mechanic or skill. Inevitably some human people will have an advantage or disadvantage at that activity. DbD is a game that relies on visual cues, audio cues, quick decision making, reflexes, etc. You can argue any of those should have more or less emphasis in the game, ultimately that's going to advantage some people and disadvantage others.
-
@MorelClaudette said:
I simply don't understand why they never explain MMR in more detail.
Now would be the perfect opportunity to do so.
I get it that they won't show a number or something to prevent bullying each others ranks (high MMR = no lifer/unemployed, low MMR = noob, no skill). They also do not need to explain what algorithms or whatever they use.
But some examples would help with understanding the actual system.
Just simple things like
- "If you play killer and get 1 kill, but 9 hooks → MMR stays the same (you would have needed 2 kills for a MMR increase)"
- "If you play survivor and get 3 out of 4 iridiscent emblems but die in the end → MMR increase".
That would help a lot of people to get the basic idea.
So I really would like the system to be laid out, but:
Just simple things like"If you play killer and get 1 kill, but 9 hooks → MMR stays the same (you would have needed 2 kills for a MMR increase)""If you play survivor and get 3 out of 4 iridiscent emblems but die in the end → MMR increase".
That would help a lot of people to get the basic idea.It's not like that as at the end of the match each individual survivor is compared to the killer (and then their current MMRs are compared to each other). So even if you do a bunch of activities that gain points, whether that results in a net gain or not isn't known until compared to the other side.
@ForTheEntity said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4112402#Comment_4112402
The point is: people who want to manipulate their MMR will find a way to MMR within the constraints they are given.
If people think they can limit their MMR by constraining their kills then we get games where people get 8 hooks and zero kills (providing the survivors unhook) and those are rather sporting games.
If people think they can limit their MMR by limiting their time in chase, hooks and kills well where does that leave us? Killers that limit their time in chase, hooks and kills? What kind of killer does that resemble now?
If people think they can limit their MMR by limiting their time in chase, hooks and kills well where does that leave us? Killers that limit their time in chase, hooks and kills? What kind of killer does that resemble now?Hypothetically, it requires the killer to not even play the match if enough factors are taken into account. Given how boring that would be, and how frequently the player would have to engage in it, its unlikely that many players would actually do it. While the current 8 hook, then let them go, would be an easy way to get around (though not one I find to be particularly worrisome).
@ForTheEntity said:
Before it was based on kills but now it's based on …what?
For those that want to raise their MMR, it's a great change. No matter what you do if you're trying your MMR will go up …or what?
I just want to understand.
I was never one to take up nasty strategies like tunneling or slugging from the start of a match. I like going for my 8 hooks before I start killing people and if they brought cake I might let them go… but even then I might end up at higher MMR even though I'm not getting kills?
I get it, I have enough hour that I shouldn't be part of the newb-welcoming squad, a role I was happy to play, but now I might just suffer no matter what I do?
If someone wants to keep their MMR lower that it should be it used to be killers could get 8 hooks and giver the survivors a sporting round… but what do they do now? Play a li bit and AFK?
Disclaimer: Not encouraging anything. Just want to know how the system works.
Before it was based on kills but now it's based on …what?For those that want to raise their MMR, it's a great change. No matter what you do if you're trying your MMR will go up …or what?I just want to understand.Survivors are graded on an individual basis. Other actions in the game, which generally (generally being an important word here) correspond to the emblem system, award points during the match. Escapes and deaths are still the preeminent point getter. Those points are compared with the other side at the end of the trial and the side with more points gains MMR (with killer vs survivor being 4 comparisons). How much you gain/lose is
1: I suspect determined by the level of difference (I'm not sure if they said this precisely)
2: Modifies by comparing starting MMRs
Beyond that, there are no plans to divulge what the actual specifics/number break downs are (based on another thread).
-
@jesterkind said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4112147#Comment_4112147
Slippery Meat is the perfect pick for that, it's thematic and also a universal perk so everyone has access to it.
The unhook notification does have legitimate use, so tying this effect to a perk is more reasonable imo
The unhook notification does have legitimate use, so tying this effect to a perk is more reasonable imoBy legitimate I'm guessing you mean the info the killer gets. I've always thought that's way too powerful for something to just be free basekit (not that you would use this phrase I think, but in the community parlance, very hand holdy basekit).
The problem I think with going the perk direction is how easily it would pair with something like Resurgence to take lots of the risks out of healing under hook. That's why I think a basekit hide of the unhook notification would make implementing a trade off much easier - something like mangled/broken off hook to also make healing under hook under the protection less easy.
-
@cammoking123 said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4111726#Comment_4111726
We do. It's called balance. In what world is two seconds of haste worth 40 seconds of exhaustion?
BHVR isn't really interested in balancing certain perks as much as nuking them. They've done it in the past and will almost certainly do it again in the future. That was the fate of SB.
-
@HoodedWildKard said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4111590#Comment_4111590
Ah wondered how long before the "git gud" would pop up. Problem with that is the skill requirement gap between the roles. Killer has a much lower skill requirement than survivor. Like a massive one. I have about 1600 hours, and as killer I often absolutely slam survivor in teams with 5-6k+ hours each, and I never enter a game and hard tunnel from the start. Conversley I have survivor games where killers with 100-300 hours get 4ks because they hard tunnel and either remove a player from the game extremely early or turn altruistic plays into snowballs to gain a bunch of pressure. It takes control of the game very early and a toddler could do it.
To "git gud" as a survivor in chase takes hundreds if not thousands of hours. Killer is much easier to pick up, even without relying on hard tunneling right off the bat, you'll regularly see killers with less than a third of the play time of their survivor opponents absolutely clap them. So by your mentality anyone who hasn't played the game for literal solid months of their lives just deserves to lose any game where a killer simply plays the cheap easy tactic.
Hard tunneling requires bare minimal competence at the game, whilst countering hard tunneling effectively requires an insane amount of hours gameplay, knowledge and reflexes that a good 70-80% of the playerbase simply doesn't possess. Just look at your example, you list genrushing and bully squads as the survivor equivalent to hard tunneling. But they are much easier to counter, there's a plethora of regression perks and bully squad tactics are much more likely to backfire and practically throw the game for survivors than secure a win. Dedicated anti tunnel perks are not great in number and on the whole are extremely weak, the only one that really works well is DS, and that is a one shot and gone. Most other anti tunnel perks like OTR etc are completely countered by simply proxying the hook and hitting the surv straight off hook and hounding them down. To effectively counter a hard tunnel you need either the tunneling target to astronomically outskill the killer and string 3 chases (2 at a major disadvantage) for 5 gens, and/or players who can pull altruistic plays without getting downed, which really means the killer needs to have the intelligence and tactical acumen of a concrete paving slab.
The only time hard tunneling hurts the killer is when the skill gap between them and the survivors is huge. It's a cheap, skilless tactic that is extremely difficult to counter, and more importantly isn't really fun for anyone involved. You remember that people are supposed to play games to have fun right? Winning by the quickest, most efficient and hard to counter playstyle is the mentality that causes people to cheat. And imo players who constantly hard tunnel are only one step up from cheaters, only because that kind of play legitimately exists due to the quirk of dbd being an asymmetric pvp game. Now with the offhook endurance actually being reduced this tactic only gets stronger.
Ah wondered how long before the "git gud" would pop up. Problem with that is the skill requirement gap between the roles.This is a good point that you explain well, but there is something that often comes to my mind about it. We all own the same game. Its not like one group of humans was assigned survivors and another killers, though that does seem to be how people treat it. I think the logical explanation for why 'survivors' seem bad in comparison to 'killers' is that just the killer role is easier (which is also how they maintain a 60% KR).
-
@AbsolutGrndZer0 said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4106929#Comment_4106929
A strawman can also be making an illogtcal comparison to shift the goalposts. Robbing a bank is in no way a reasonable comparison to tunneling, and therefore THAT is why your argument is a strawman.
I'm really surprised to see the thread revived after 11 days, especially without it being anything related to the topic.
Anyway, fallacies aren't just buzz words, they have meanings.
Strawman - someone argues against a position that the other person doesn't have
Moving the goalposts (not sure where this came from) - changing the demands for what evidence is needed to prove a point. Example: show me a game - okay, that doesn't count, show me five games - those don't count, show me 20 games.
I'm not doing either of those. I'm (twice, you keep ignoring the second comparison along with the general explanation) comparing your reasoning to other, clearly wrong (edit: just for clarity, being this is your focus of posts, the example is meant to be an obviously extreme scenario to demonstrate the fallacy you are committing), situations to demonstrate why its incorrect (a false equivalence). You don't have an answer for that so you seem to just be deflecting.
Anyway, the issue remains pretty simple - Just because some 'rules' that people try to create are wrong, doesn't mean all 'rules' are wrong
-
Is there any reason you guys can think of that these timers must be the same duration?I guess there's a little worry that it would be more confusing for new players 'you have A for 10, B for 5 after that, and then C for another 5'.
That said, yeah, I think splitting up the off hook protections so they have different times would be a good idea.
-
@Piruluk said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4111092#Comment_4111092
I think this new system might be even worse, maybe now even if you did a bare minimum and didnt escape, you still wont lose mmr and easily gain. Why is this a problem?
Because according to new mmr everybody outside of the absolute worst will be "high mmr". Either you gain easily, or you dont lose mmr easily, same thing.
I dont even understand why people care about the invisible mmr, so the system kill or escape was good enough.
The problem was always that streamers hated when had to wait games for say 10 minutes to get according players to skill level, so mmr ignored completely, just so the top few percent get instant or fast matchmaking, and then there is dodging, which destroys matchmaking anyway.
So what will the be impact?
None. Or getting worse.
I think this new system might be even worse, maybe now even if you did a bare minimum and didnt escape, you still wont lose mmr and easily gain. Why is this a problem?That I don't think is correct. MMR still works off one side up, one side down, and (I think on this part) a 1 to 1 survivor to killer comparison. So if the survivor goes up 10, the killer goes down 10. The issue is whether what they have is actually anymore reflective of skill than what existed.
I dont even understand why people care about the invisible mmr, so the system kill or escape was good enough.This is true. I wouldn't even be making this post if BHVR had never promoted they were doing it, built up hype around it, and had a livestream about it. It's made players expect something better, but we aren't actually going to learn how it works, and things will still probably feel the same. If it had been an off handed change - "hey, we're tweaking MMR to incorporate some additional factors into the rating at the end of the match, we think this will yield a slight improvement" - I wouldn't care. But they've made players expect something that I think will leave them sorely disappointed.
@lovlor said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4111093#Comment_4111093
But I don't think queue time is a valid reason to matchmake weak players with strong players. This is very unfair for the weak and can cause high frustration. I personally play mostly swf only and 4k hours now. There are matches (not rare) that I see how the killer do the first chase and knows this is a free 4out. I can even watch tiktok while I'm doing gen I don't even need to pay attention. BTW survivor queue time is almost instant at night, meaning there are many killers in the queue at the same time for their system to choose. However this still happens often. Imagine the lobby for killers when they have minutes queue time and they are given very few options when they finish their queue. They will be given very possibly weak players as they are the majority(That's my understanding of queue, might be wrong)
But I don't think queue time is a valid reason to matchmake weak players with strong players.I don't think any of us do, but BHVR seems to disagree.
-
@Mandy said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4110996#Comment_4110996
there's no plans to give the exact maths, no current plans at least. I can't speak about future as that could change, but for right now its not even in discussion.
Thank you, I appreciate it. I think its better for the community that everyone knows that for discussions going forward.
@Piruluk said:
Hm very good points, that means you will get bad MMR if you dont farm points from now on?
As discussed above, we won't know the exact breakdowns. Potentially? It really depends on how they weigh things because its NOT the emblem system where both sides could go up.
People have already voiced the worry about slugging killers and gen rushing survivors staying at lower MMRs. As I mentioned above, on the survivor side I think doing a lot of different things okay will be given more MMR than doing one thing really well, but whether that is an appreciable difference is impossible to say if things run in the background. That does create the potential there will be really amazing chase survivors (as an example) who never do anything but chase who stay at lower MMR than they would under the current system.
On the killer side it feels like a tunneling /end game build could get a lot of 3/4ks, but also not pick up much under the Gatekeeper/Malicious 'emblems'. Again without weighs impossible to know the degree of impacts.
There's going to be a lot of wait and see, which will be followed by many, many guesses.
-
@Mandy said:
https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/4110918#Comment_4110918
I agree for your final point there, players will still blame MMR - that's an unfortunate fact that happens in pretty much all games. There's no system that's perfect and its especially hard in an asymetrical game.
Kills and Escapes will still matter, its just that now they're not the only thing - it should address other things in a match, and I think that's been a lot of what players have said over the last few years. There are definitely big parts of that which do make sense - kills and escapes are one of the main constants in the game - so I don't think we're disagreeing here.
The game has changed a lot from what it was a few years ago, as have the players. We recognised that we could improve the system on how we calculate players MMR and we've worked to do that. Its been running in the background for a while as a kind of test (not impacting games, not used for matchmaking etc) and the data is looking good on it so far. It might need tweaking when its Live, we'll be keeping a close eye on it and making any adjustments as necessary.
I have a feeling this is something that can't be answered, but: will we the players, even if we don't know our own MMRs, actually know how the MMR breaks down (weighs) the various activities. Or will the exact specifics be a mystery, just that its more than escapes/deaths?