Gnarly

@Hoodied said:
Winning as killer is also losing

Can feel that way in matches.

in Unspoken Rules Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@TheMadCat said:
When you crouch under the hook right after being unhooked or right after finishing a generator, it means: "Can you heal me, please?"
When a Killer hit the air while carrying me, I understand they want me to stop wiggling because they want to bring me somewhere. I had a Bubba who wanted to hook me in the basement. He hit the air two or three times before I stopped wiggling, as I eventually understood what he was asking for. I was the last Survivor alive, so I saw no reason to not let him hooking where he wanted to. (He got the three others in the basement, so I thought he had a challenge to be done.)
But there is one I still don't know what it means, and I hope I don't use it the wrong way. I shake my arms when I'm hooked to let people know that no one is coming for me. As soon as I see someone coming my way, I stop. I've heard it means the Killer is camping, but each time someone did that in my lobby, the Killer wasn't camping at all, so I thought it was to say: "Come save me, please!"
(I mean, it was what you asked for? English is not my native language, sorry if I misunderstood a word from your message.)

You understand my post well. I wasn't aware of the shake the arms on hook. Noted though.

in Unspoken Rules Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@PureDoctorMain said:
I like to give survivors who genuinely out play me more than once hatch if I can. But I guess thats more of a personal thing.

You definitely aren't the only one👌

in Unspoken Rules Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@[Deleted User] said:
I don't think gen times are an issue at all. The first chase is hugely important to the outcome of the match, but that goes both ways. If the killer commits to a chase for 90 seconds and can't get a down, the match is basically over unless they can snowball. If the killer gets a quick early down, though, they're in the drivers seat for the rest of the match.
CI is a great way to slow down the early game for killers that start slow and probably won't be able to secure a quick hook.
I would be okay with some sort of an early game mechanic to take a bit of the weight off of that first chase but just slapping on a repair speed penalty is not necessary in my opinion.

That's fair, just actual gen rushing seems to be luck base and can tilt a killer for just trying to find someone at times.

Still would need to support survivors who are down a guy or 2...Like they need a chance. 3 Gens and 2 people left, THAT'S GG.

in Gens Still a Problem? Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@Red_Beard said:
Someone made a very good post about this a long time ago, I think it may have been @NMCKE. It was essentially about why tunneling the first person out of the match was so effective because once you got down to three survivors gen progress almost came to a standstill and if there weren’t many gens done before that time it seemed almost impossible for them to win. I think there was a similar suggestion of repair efficiency based on number of people remaining that could possibly alleviate the need to tunnel, incentivized the remaining survivors to still work gens instead of hiding and waiting for the killer to kill the others and maybe even make the hatch an unnecessary mechanic.

100% The game is balanced for a 4v1 aspect. When it's a 3v1 or 2v1, the Killer can have a scary advantage. I have had people DC with 2 to 3 gens left and the 3 others die, due to pressure being more tight on them.

in Gens Still a Problem? Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@Airless said:
If a change to generator speeds is needed, PLEASE don't just make them take longer to do. Actually doing gens is the most part of survivor, don't make it worse

I understand. Don't want to make players waste more time sure, but matches go by really fast at times and you can either make gens take longer, or add more objectives. Either way it takes away from being a survivor.

I do definitely know what you mean though.

in Gens Still a Problem? Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@Sup3rCatTree said:
Gens need to be changed, similar to HSH (Needing to get items for it, etc.) and then they can rework all the gen regression perks like ruin, etc...
It will make the game a lot healthier and fun to play

Definitely. I jusy suggested an idea that idk if it even help, but it be better than what it is now ya know.

in Gens Still a Problem? Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@Clünge said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2210162#Comment_2210162
Exactly.
Survivors can render the perk almost useless if they stealth around and search for totems, mentally map out gen locations & safe loop locations. However, a lot aren't that smart and/or just too darn impatient.

Perk CAN'T BE USELESS, because it buys you time NO MATTER what you do. If they do totems, cool don't do HEX builds. Do more gen cucks.

I again don't really care for the perk, I just have it being ran against me as much as BT and DS was 15 months ago. That's my problem.

in Corrupt Intervention Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@Swagger69 said:
its pretty annoying to run into. lets say youre playing survivor and the gen immediately gets blocked, that means youll have to use your sprint burst. its also pretty annoying to have a 3 gen in the first 3 minutes of the match. the perk is fine

It also covers a lot of ground and the survivors are always by the blocked generators. JUST MATCH AFTER MATCH, its breaks ya mentally

in Corrupt Intervention Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@Khar said:
Survivors literally start next to gens, which they can begin repairing not 5 seconds into the match, and you think Corrupt Intervention is cheap?

It's not the perks fault it helps balancing the game. My issue is it is overused in the matches I get and there isn't anything to deserve the lockdown. It's free, NOED isn't free even. Just overused due to the current state of game. Thats the main issue

in Corrupt Intervention Comment by Gnarly May 24, 2021

@Hex_AverageStudent said:
so is garret welling the wolf and the survivor?
also feral frenzy is already used in the game, its the legions power,
but other than that its an awesome concept. I especially liked the story.

Garret is survivor but turns into werewolf when he is killer. So entity is using the monster side of him. He isn't aware though.

Also is Feral Frenzy was the perk name. Changed it cuz forgot that Legion abilities name was that. Thanks for the reminder

in FAN-MADE Chapter(Out for Blood and More) Comment by Gnarly May 22, 2021

@MrPenguin said:
Spirit because Spirit lol. We all know why.
"we know everyone loves Michael."
I don't like Michael at all and I know there's others that don't as well.

What is wrong with Michael? He is the most fun and balanced killers considered by most.

in Least Fun Killer? Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@musstang62 said:
I've played against roughly 50 ghostfaces and I still have absolutely no idea how the ######### you're supposed to break him out of stealth. It seems to depend less on what you do and more on the day of the week. Drives me bonkers

My problem is I look STRAIGHT AT HIM AND WE DO A STARING CONTEST...still doesn't break out of stealth and now I'm exposed. Then mid chase I can break him randomly out of it.

in Least Fun Killer? Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@HaunterofShadows said:
Dislike the players behind them

That's fair😂

in Least Fun Killer? Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@BSVben said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2203381#Comment_2203381
Just joking bud. There are definitely some interesting aspects to your killer, but he seems underpowered as the others have mentioned.

That's good though. Rather buff a killer than nerf em. So I try to b safe ya know. Total aware bit underpowered. But Legion mixed with trapper be kinda cool to me.

in FAN-MADE Chapter(Weaving Another's Death) Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@Mystoc said:
these mixtures make no sense most cause mending which can only happen if you injured the one gens, are u saying it also injures them? plague can infect gens but it takes a long time to for that reuslt in injury, you did say you were working on them though so i will ignore the power
my domain is a better territorial imperative, and it can active while the killer is still in the basement horrible perk the promotes camping people in the basement this should only active if the killer is x amount away from basement, this is also pseudo make your choice as well this perk if it will stay how it needs to be nerfed alot
https://deadbydaylight.fandom.com/wiki/Territorial_Imperative#:~:text=Territorial%20Imperative%20has%20a%20cool,30%2F25%2F20%20seconds.&text=of%20all%20Killers-,Unlocks%20potential%20in%20your%20Aura%2Dreading%20ability.,cool%2Ddown%20of%20several%20seconds.
edit misread self assured its reversed borrowed time which is a big nono one the perks can overlap and one do nothing, and also who would ever run this over BT basicly if all for survivors have this its the same affect of BT but assures they have it 100% if it isnt this perk could be rework of BT but never exist along side it
the other perks for survivor and killer I like

Problem is no one seems to run it whoever I play with and I don't appreciate the farm😅. More of a frustration and DS just has that stigma so I don't like using it.

I do understand what mean. Appreciate the opinions.

in FAN-MADE Chapter(Weaving Another's Death) Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@Critical_Fish said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/250597/fan-made-chapter-weaving-anothers-death
Well, one, the power is kinda meh? Also, why does a 115% speed Killer have a 28 meter terror radius?
Tampering is literally useless. It might be nice finding slugged Survivors, but only might be. The time isn't long enough for them to be hooked, unhooked, and then for you to get good use out of it. The Killer also has no movement abilities or slowdown, legitimately making them seem like a worse Legion, who at least has a decent speed boost in his power. Also how long does it take to reload and apply the mixtures? Does it slow them down to throw the mixture toss? Why is this Killer so much like Clown?
My Domain is kinda gimmicky but it's not like its bad or anything, with Territorial Imperative it makes going into the basement a death sentence, but it also makes long distance basement camping as Demo, Hag, or any high mobility Killer even better, so I'm iffy on it.
Ain't No Rest is actually really stupid. Picture yourself as a Survivor against a Doctor with a Calm addon. Already not very fun, right? Then you also realize after using your Sprint Burst that you aren't recovering from exhaustion at all. Then when you use Deliverance you don't recover from Broken either. That sounds ######### miserable. Also, this perk has no perk tiers. I'd say it should be reworked.
Maneater is better Pop Goes The Weasel, which is potentially among the top 5 best killer perks in the game. Don't.
Self Assured is just Decisive Strike before its nerf with a spice of pre-rework Borrowed Time. Don't.
Burning Flame is... cute? There's not really a point to it honestly.
For Dragged from the Ashes, how long does the healing bonus last?

I am definitely open to those suggestions and criticisms. I prefer a weak killer that can be buffed later than a Killer that destroys everything. So I was a bit conservative on the abilities.

Drag From The Ashes it be 40/50/60 seconds.

Do appreciate that fair points you make❤

in FAN-MADE Chapter(Weaving Another's Death) Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@BSVben said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2201992#Comment_2201992
And on top of all of that, Greg O'Malley is just a straight up terrible name.

Dang😂...it's open to change

in FAN-MADE Chapter(Weaving Another's Death) Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@Tsulan said:
Tunneling is one of the side effects of the current gen speed.
When a killer loses 3 gens in his first chase, then he'll try to get at least that one kill.

Not one gen got done😂

in Deliberate Tunneling... Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@Zesty said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2197591#Comment_2197591
Gonna have to disagree with you on that. A Trickster with actual mechanical aim, good map knowledge and knows when to use their power, can kill even the best survivors this game has. He is actually quite strong, just most people CBA to learn him as he is so difficult, ill just be in the background decimating at rank 1!

Like he is just huntress with extra steps...still solid killer

in Who is the Worse Killer? Comment by Gnarly May 21, 2021

@Reinami said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/250924/deliberate-tunneling
Did you bring a key, tbag, flashlight click, have OOO, or otherwise do something that would be perceived as toxic?

I WOULD OF NOT posted this if I was being toxic. A Zarina had a flashlight, and my friend Nea had a key...I got tunneled for maybe playing Quentin?

in Deliberate Tunneling... Comment by Gnarly May 20, 2021

@NoelleMina said:
Some people just tunnel and/or camp without reason, other than to maybe get hate messages to chuckle at.
Otherwise, some people will just do it.
Try not to let it demotivate you or anything. 😣

It doesn't...just felt personally attacked for no reason, like I try not to be toxic as a survivor since I play killer. I don't like upsetting other killers, but that guy just rude.

in Deliberate Tunneling... Comment by Gnarly May 20, 2021

@Trickstaaaaa said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2199595#Comment_2199595
Yeah I don't think you ever played trickster. Because he actually plays more similar to the plague in the way her vomit works. They both have the same counter, you try to avoid short loops vs both in that way. But how ever plague is way more stronger than him since she can throw her vomit in jungle gyms and shack and actually get you. And believe it or not gideon is one trickster best maps if you are on the top floor. But that is the thing for trickster you have to play vs survivors who know how don't know how to properly loop. Because any looping that is not short is very effective vs the trickster. While with legion since he is 115% it's not easy to loop him like the trickster. But I get that survivors splitting up hurts legion but that is the case for any killer. But legion is able to travel quickly across the map with his power and you can get to survivors more quickly. While even with the trickster huge maps hurts him badly since he is a close range killer, at best you can get some medium range shots. But as I said being injured is a pressure maker, it's a great way to add pressure while with the trickster you can't injured everyone with one blow. I actually think ghost face might be a bit weaker than legion honestly.

Trickster is not close range. His knives go a good amount of distance. Might be like Huntress were he sucks more on consoles due to aiming...but I never had a struggle with 8 hits. He kind of like bubba, got to control the survivors direction. Legion is helpless in those situations.

If we look at Plague, she is worse like Legion, because both can just be palyed around the abilities. Trickster will always be able to use his ability. It has extra steps, but it can easily save you time from loops. Legion and Plague can't do anything about them.

in Who is the Worse Killer? Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

@Trickstaaaaa said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2199470#Comment_2199470
Played plague last night vs full red rank squad and managed to get a 3k. Played the trickster last night as well in the same map too Gideon meat plant, and only managed to get 1k but a decent amount of hooks. I think the reason people don't like to play the plague is because she can be kind of boring to play at the beginning. But I do see a couple of legions, and legion can injure everyone, and thus have pressure in the game and he is 115% so I have lost way more legions than tricksters. I only lost 2 times to a trickster since his release. But I'm telling you one of my friend who does not know how to loop at all, even managed to loop him the other day when played vs one, so take as you will. I think you should play the trickster in red ranks too see how hard it truly is vs competent survivors not even goods ones just regular ones.

Trickster can do something to end chases. He has more steps than Huntress, but he has the same solution. Depending on the map, you can be screwed and Gideon is a hard map for both. Too many objects to hide behind, however most maps favor the range killers.

Legion is worse in open maps, and people just love th character so much they play him at any rank, like Michael Myers. If everyone is separated from each other doing gens, Legion can't use his ability. I bring distressing and he NEEDS that perk so much. He is never going to down anyone through his ability. If all four survivors are injured, then his ability is even worsen. You can force them to mend sure, but why do that when you can get them down, except...you habe nothing to help you in chases because ypur ability slows you down from stun when it's over.

in Who is the Worse Killer? Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

@Trickstaaaaa said:
Trickster range ability is worthless outside of short loops or unless you are running in the open close range. There is a reason you don't tricksters in rank 1, he is the weakest killer vs shack and jungle gyms. He has no snowball potential and he has to focus one survivor at time, and you have commit to getting one health state down if you throw your knifes. Also his 1 on 1 chase is not even good if you know how loop in jungles gyms or shack. Even my friend who does not know how to loop managed to loop him for a while the other day. Even when I play trapper in rank 1 I can get more downs, and not struggle as bad.

Ah but do you see Legions or Plagues? I THINK NOT...at least he can down someone with his ability

in Who is the Worse Killer? Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

By far most known and beloved next to the NSFW Redfield Bloodline meme.

in Jill Sandwhich Charm? Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

@Dabihwow said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2198442#Comment_2198442
Who is Barry, never heard of Barry. I know who Wesker is but after his death he just kinda felt like he existed but at the same time he didn't. Like his presence was still in the games afterwords but it only by a hair

You don't know who Barry is? Did you even play Resident Evil 1? Jill Sandwhich and all that

in Putting a bullet in the RE8 Theories once and for all. Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

@Almo said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2198335#Comment_2198335
Because this is Resident Evil (at least the early games). These camera angles give the game control over what you see and how you see it. It's meant to be able to generate the kind of fear movies can do but games with "normal" controls and cameras cannot.
Having said that, I can see why newer audiences find it strange and annoying. :) Also, I know that games can make some kinds of fear that movies cannot.

Just got adjust the brain. I struggled terribly with the first game game, but after beating every RE Game out there. Including the Wii games😂, I have to say RE4 and RE2 Remake are the best I think.

Over the shoulder and still gave him me the same feeling of tense and uneasyness that RE 0, 1, 2, and 3 had.

in Putting a bullet in the RE8 Theories once and for all. Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

@Avignon said:
Im honestly wondering if the person who made this mains surv , killer or plays both because there's maybe 2 killers that belong on the poll :P
It's actually funny people think Legion and Plague are weak because they're "just" M1 killers (btw a 115% M1 Killer is like a perfectly average like B tier killer) and then put Clown in the same poll , an anti - loop killer.
I'd say Trapper simply because Pig and Trapper and both kinda rng based, but at least with pig you're RNG kicks in at the end of a successful chase so you're doing two things at once.

I main Killer, but have played a lot of each over the years.

Clown has a limit on his bottles and a good survivor can make clown waste three bottles in a loop and if he reloads then that's wasted time and more space from you and the survivor. Clown was garbage before his buff and now he is tolerable.

Legion and Plague abilities always will make them low tier because you can play around it. You can deal with being injured and if you have iron will then Legion has no chance. Also if you have 4 survivors spawning away from each other, that hurts those two specifically a lot more. Legion can't kill with his ability and if he uses to catch up to a survivor, he loses ground from his stun after FRENZY. I say HE cuz I play Frank mostly.

My Most Played Killers

1. Clown

2. Leatherface

3. Pyramid Head

4. Legion(TBH IDK WHY)

5. Freddy Krueger

6. Michael Myers

7. Spirit

8. Ghostface

10. Oni

in Who is the Worse Killer? Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

@Dabihwow said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2198331#Comment_2198331
While I do agree but to be honest I never caught on with it I had the crippling mindset that it was another zombie apocalypse game with something else added to it, at that point I was so desensitized by the stereotype before I looked at the RE trilogy, and it just never clicked with me like 7 or the others

I believe that you don't know how my dad felt about the series in the 90s...maybe nowadays it can be seen by younger people, but RE7 and RE8 will never match the ICONIC characters. From Wesker, Leon, Claire, Jill, Ada, Barry, Chris, etc

in Putting a bullet in the RE8 Theories once and for all. Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

@Dabihwow said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2198287#Comment_2198287
Why not both the old and new, I never played RE until recently so it would only be fair if some of the newer games have something to say

Yea but without the old the new would of never happen. RE1 is the definition of horror survival, set the standard.

If u needed one, RE OG trilogy would be on the Horror of Fame.

in Putting a bullet in the RE8 Theories once and for all. Comment by Gnarly May 19, 2021

@Woodywool said:
https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2197678#Comment_2197678
I'm playing with nothing since the beginning of 2021. It's my personal experiment that became a regular thing atm lol
I played a lot as perkless Myers before All-Kill chapter (was trying to get rank 1 from 5). And I did but it took SO LONG.
Myers is the worst killer for some reasons:
he has limited power
if you're going against good SWF that saw you at the start you'll have not a good time for trying to get tier 2
he has a lot of bugs/outdated mechanics (bugged stalking bar if you're stalking too long, no collision when Myers is stalking, no stalking actions if survivor runs ~~trough~~ through the Shape)
Everyone loves Myers! And respect him. I rarely see the person that gave up cause of Myers (doesn't count spooky Myers build with T1)
And even that he has a small TR in tier 2 and good vault speed and slightly increased lunge at tier 3, he's a pure M1 killer.
Legion (perkless) is better a lot because:
they (Legion) can injure a lot survivors and experienced Legion can create a good pressure to surv team.
Even if the survivors will not heal, they all can be downed by 1 hit
A LOT OF PEOPLE hate Legion and give up or not playing too serious against him
against not experienced survivors you can grab some survivors that hiding in the locker while your ability is activated by hitting with it to another survivor earlier or get a free hits with Legion's power the group of survivors that already finished to heal each other almost in your face
Trapper (perkless) is my #2 of worst killer in the game but he feels slightly powerful even with no addons than Myers:
you can still use shack basement and against not good survivors mostly of the time it's a free win for you
good prepared area has a potential to WIPE all members of the team. I have a lot of games when I've one hooked guy, chasing another and he got trapped and after some seconds another one got in the trap too. After some seconds, you have one hooked and 2 dying survivors and it's a strong thing (even works against good survivors) but it depends on random sometimes
3 gened situation and prepared area of deadly traps are your plan B
and with your traps, you can deny god loops by setting a trap in the movement route or under pallet/window
if you're expert on him and a bit creative you can set some traps in not obvious places that survivors usually use to move around the map but never decide to check these places for a trap
Trickster (perkless) is weak and at the same time can be strong (in some scenarios):
on some maps that have a lot of small boxes loops, he's a decent killer
you can use some holes in the walls/shack to throw your blades and even down him by doing it
like huntress, he sucks in short loop with a huge rock (for example) and Jungle Gyms and T L wall can waste a lot of your time but you always can don't accept these chases and leave
even that a lot of people think that he's like a huntress that requires not a good skill that she needs to be good on her I completely disagree. You need to keep in mind that each hand pose throw has unique crosshair and deal with it. Even that he sometimes can down survivors really fast but Huntress still feels better.
Anyway, he doesn't need to stalk/prepared the area for downing the survivor fast. And if a survivor in a deadzone, good Trickster have a hight chance to down him in the next 6-8 seconds.
Note: it's my personal game experience that I have by playing with all perkless killers almost a half a year and you'll probably can disagree with some things and IT'S OK.

I understand what you are sayin about Michael, but he has a game changer in Tier 3. Without add-ons he can get to Tier 2 easily as you have no Terror Radius. Myers can maybe even pull off a free grab. He has outdated design, but he is still better off than Trapper if both have NO add-ons. Stats don't even back up that he is bad. Man is almost at 3Ks a match. He is just SOLID as a killer, but hard to play. Burger King Myers is more doable for me than No Add-On Trapper😂

Every Killer has bugs and Michael has more than average, but he is a Fun, Balance Killer. ALSO YOU GET A MOONWALK