Skip to content

Question

Phasmamain Phasmamain
in General Discussions

A dev walks up to you and says you have to remove one from each of these categories

  1. Survivor (Their teachable go too)
  2. Killer (Their teachables go too)
  3. Survivor addon
  4. Killer addon
  5. Map
  6. Offering(This can be one type of addon like luck offerings)
  7. Survivor perk
  8. Killer perk

What would you choose? I’ll share my list

  1. Jake
  2. Nurse
  3. BNP
  4. Scalped Top Knot
  5. Midwich
  6. Luck offerings
  7. Hope
  8. Bamboozle

Comments

  • GeneralV GeneralV

    Honestly, I don't know how to answer this question. I want to bring things back, not remove them.

  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @GeneralV said:

    Honestly, I don't know how to answer this question. I want to bring things back, not remove them.

    Judging by your other posts you want old Freddy back which is fair. I think he was kinda bad but had potential

  • Gay_Police_Dept Gay_Police_Dept

    7 - urban evasion

    8 - Self care

    I don't care about the rest, they can stay.

  • Pulsar Pulsar
    1. Laurie
    2. Twins
    3. BNP
    4. Iridescent Head
    5. Midwich
    6. Map Offerings
    7. Iron Will
    8. NOED
  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @Gay_Police_Dept said:

    7 - urban evasion

    8 - Self care

    I don't care about the rest, they can stay.

    As a solo player I feel this

  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @Pulsar said:

    1. Laurie
    2. Twins
    3. BNP
    4. Iridescent Head
    5. Midwich
    6. Map Offerings
    7. Iron Will
    8. NOED

    Fair list though I think twins could be cool with some tweaks

  • GeneralV GeneralV

    @Phasmamain said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2044949#Comment_2044949

    Judging by your other posts you want old Freddy back which is fair. I think he was kinda bad but had potential

    You know me, my friend. I do want my Old Killer back. But there is more, if I could I would bring Splinters back, Moonlight offerings, Old Nurse, Old Billy, among other things.

  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @GeneralV said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2044954#Comment_2044954

    You know me, my friend. I do want my Old Killer back. But there is more, if I could I would bring Splinters back, Moonlight offerings, Old Nurse, Old Billy, among other things.

    You really want 5 blink nurse back? Moonlight offerings would also make playing against blendettes miserable. Splinters and billy I’d be fine with though

  • GeneralV GeneralV

    @Phasmamain said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2044977#Comment_2044977

    You really want 5 blink nurse back? Moonlight offerings would also make playing against blendettes miserable. Splinters and billy I’d be fine with though

    Claudette main, I can't help it :) Besides, there was an offering for brightest moonlight. As for Nurse, I just want her old kit back, her add-ons could see some changes again.

    I am glad you agree with Splinters and Billy. His nerf was unnecessary. And I hated that they removed Splinters all of a sudden. I spent so many Bloodpoints... for nothing.

  • Pior_Morte Pior_Morte

    1 - Ash (because who cares about Ash and his perks)

    2- TWINS TWINS TWINS (######### the twins)

    3 - Blood Amber

    4 - Iri Head

    5 - HADDONFIELD (######### haddonfield)

    6 - Mary's Letter (######### Midwich)

    7 - SELF-CARE (I would say DS but it's getting nerfed)

    8 - NOED (I don't like running detective's Hunch every match)

  • Aven_Fallen Aven_Fallen
    1. Survivor --> Ash, has basically no right to exist anymore, only good thing was the cashgrab MoM. His Perks are bad and he is annoying.
    2. Killer --> Spirit. Really, ######### Spirit.
    3. Survivor addon --> Odd Bulbs. Just useless, waste of BPs.
    4. Killer addon --> Berus Toxin, one of my most hated Add Ons and wanted to go for something else than the obvious Iri Heads.
    5. Map --> Saloon, hate this Map with a passion.
    6. Offering --> Hatch Offerings
    7. Survivor perk --> Object of Obsession
    8. Killer perk --> NOED


  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @Pior_Morte said:

    1 - Ash (because who cares about Ash and his perks)

    2- TWINS TWINS TWINS (######### the twins)

    3 - Blood Amber

    4 - Iri Head

    5 - HADDONFIELD (######### haddonfield)

    6 - Mary's Letter (######### Midwich)

    7 - SELF-CARE (I would say DS but it's getting nerfed)

    8 - NOED (I don't like running detective's Hunch every match)

    Good list! Didn’t think about blood amber but that needs to go tbh

  • Alionis Alionis
    1. No teachables need to go. Just because a perk isn't meta (looking at Aven, here), doesn't mean there aren't people who find them useful and fun.
    2. ditto
    3. Styptic agent as I don't like cheap second chances.
    4. Iridescent head, cause that add-on only causes grievances.
    5. None, but Haddonfield needed a rework yesterday rather than tomorrow
    6. None, I want the moonlight offerings back.
    7. Decisive strike, same reasoning as styptic agent
    8. NOED, same reasoning as DS and styptic agent, despite us being able to cleanse it before it activates.
  • GeneralV GeneralV

    @Alionis said:

    1. No teachables need to go. Just because a perk isn't meta (looking at Aven, here), doesn't mean there aren't people who find them useful and fun.
    2. ditto
    3. Styptic agent as I don't like cheap second chances.
    4. Iridescent head, cause that add-on only causes grievances.
    5. None, but Haddonfield needed a rework yesterday rather than tomorrow
    6. None, I want the moonlight offerings back.
    7. Decisive strike, same reasoning as styptic agent
    8. NOED, same reasoning as DS and styptic agent, despite us being able to cleanse it before it activates.

    YES! Embrace Moonlight!

    BringItBack.png


  • Marc_go_solo Marc_go_solo

    1) Ace Visconti - Mainly to do with his perks. They're just very underwhelming. Even his best: "Ace In The Hole" isn't worth it, compared to many other perks.

    2) Bubba "Junior" Sawyer - He is the killer that can be most abused by toxic players.

    3) Brand New Part - Can vastly decimate a trial. Especially with other gen-boosting perks and toolbox add-ons.

    4) Iridescent Head - Vastly decimates the trial, especially when using "Infantry Belt"

    5) Rotten Fields - It is just painfully boring and vacant.

    6) Vigo's hatch offerings - Having no idea where the hatch will spawn adds more to the match. Holding a key as well makes it more frustrating.

    7) Slippery Meat - It has done nothing for me, even with luck add-ons. My poor luck makes it too painful.

    8) Coulrophobia - Has barely any impact

  • Kira4Evr Kira4Evr


    1. Steve.
    2. Deathslinger.
    3. Rubber Gloves.
    4. Iridescent head.
    5. Léry's Memorial Institute, aka, The Hospital.
    6. Shattered Glasses, aka, The Hospital Offering.
    7. Buckle Up.
    8. Franklin's Demise


  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @Marc_go_solo said:

    1) Ace Visconti - Mainly to do with his perks. They're just very underwhelming. Even his best: "Ace In The Hole" isn't worth it, compared to many other perks.

    2) Bubba "Junior" Sawyer - He is the killer that can be most abused by toxic players.

    3) Brand New Part - Can vastly decimate a trial. Especially with other gen-boosting perks and toolbox add-ons.

    4) Iridescent Head - Vastly decimates the trial, especially when using "Infantry Belt"

    5) Rotten Fields - It is just painfully boring and vacant.

    6) Vigo's hatch offerings - Having no idea where the hatch will spawn adds more to the match. Holding a key as well makes it more frustrating.

    7) Slippery Meat - It has done nothing for me, even with luck add-ons. My poor luck makes it too painful.

    8) Coulrophobia - Has barely any impact

    Good choices! I like coulophobia quite a lot though

  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @Aven_Fallen said:

    1. Survivor --> Ash, has basically no right to exist anymore, only good thing was the cashgrab MoM. His Perks are bad and he is annoying.
    2. Killer --> Spirit. Really, ######### Spirit.
    3. Survivor addon --> Odd Bulbs. Just useless, waste of BPs.
    4. Killer addon --> Berus Toxin, one of my most hated Add Ons and wanted to go for something else than the obvious Iri Heads.
    5. Map --> Saloon, hate this Map with a passion.
    6. Offering --> Hatch Offerings
    7. Survivor perk --> Object of Obsession
    8. Killer perk --> NOED

    Yeah hatch offerings were a mistake

  • KiwiCoattails KiwiCoattails
    • Ace because his perks are garbagé
    • Plague
    • Brand New Part
    • Iridescent Head
    • Coldwind Farm
    • EVERY map offering
    • Buckle Up
    • Monstrous Shrine
  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @[Deleted User] said:

    1. Laurie
    2. Freddy
    3. BNP
    4. Iridescent Head
    5. Lery's
    6. Shrouds
    7. Unbreakable
    8. Bambozlee

    I feel like slugging would be too strong with the removal of unbreakable but that’s just my opinion

  • EvilJoshy EvilJoshy

    1:Claudette. Blends in with everything.

    2:Spirit. Not because I hate going against her but I hate it when I get dailys for her. I suck with her and I play Nurse.

    3:BNP

    4:Torn bookmark. What is the point of a 3rd blink if you can't go through walls?

    5:Hawkins. No tall grass. My trapper doesn't like that.

    6:The veil that causes all survivors to spawn separate. Just makes them do gens faster. If they are on the same gen I can disrupt that.

    7:OoO

    8:Furtive Chase. WTH is the point of a smaller TR "during" a chase? They already know you are there.

  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @EvilJoshy said:

    1:Claudette. Blends in with everything.

    2:Spirit. Not because I hate going against her but I hate it when I get dailys for her. I suck with her and I play Nurse.

    3:BNP

    4:Torn bookmark. What is the point of a 3rd blink if you can't go through walls?

    5:Hawkins. No tall grass. My trapper doesn't like that.

    6:The veil that causes all survivors to spawn separate. Just makes them do gens faster. If they are on the same gen I can disrupt that.

    7:OoO

    8:Furtive Chase. WTH is the point of a smaller TR "during" a chase? They already know you are there.

    In my opinion nurse’s torn bookmark should be her base power in exchange for 110% move speed

    Great list though

  • Dr_Loomis Dr_Loomis
    1. Survivor: Quentin. Crap perks, crap remake, crap character, crap likeness. Crap.
    2. Killer: Trickster. He's not for me.
    3. Survivor addon: Brand New Part. 4 of these at the start...
    4. Killer addon: Huntress' Iridescent Head. Without a bloody doubt. This needs to go.
    5. Map: Swamp. I hate that place.
    6. Offering: Decrease mist Reagent. Pointless.
    7. Survivor perk: OoO. Just an accessory for trolls.
    8. Killer perk: Monstrous Shrine. It's got no real use.


  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @Dr_Loomis said:

    1. Survivor: Quentin. Crap perks, crap remake, crap character, crap likeness. Crap.
    2. Killer: Trickster. He's not for me.
    3. Survivor addon: Brand New Part. 4 of these at the start...
    4. Killer addon: Huntress' Iridescent Head. Without a bloody doubt. This needs to go.
    5. Map: Swamp. I hate that place.
    6. Offering: Decrease mist Reagent. Pointless.
    7. Survivor perk: OoO. Just an accessory for trolls.
    8. Killer perk: Monstrous Shrine. It's got no real use.

    The remake was pretty bad but Quentin was quite good imo. Kyle gallner portrayed the character well

  • ALostPuppy ALostPuppy

    1. Ace's teachables are worthless so he can go

    2. The Twins are a war crime and their one fun perk got nerfed so...yeah, get out of the game please and thank you

    3. All survivor add-ons are fine tbh, but BNPs are probably the one I'd wanna see go

    4. I see scalped topknot more than the other dumb add-ons. Almost never see Tombstone piece, iri head, pinky finger etc

    5. Please just delete Haddonfield for the love of everything

    6. Map offerings needed to be removed years ago

    7. Dead hard, because dead hard for distance makes me lose brain cells whenever I see it

    8. Mindbreaker because it's OP. Nah, real answer would probably be bamboozle. Hate that brain-dead perk with a passion.

  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @ALostPuppy said:

    1. Ace's teachables are worthless so he can go

    2. The Twins are a war crime and their one fun perk got nerfed so...yeah, get out of the game please and thank you

    3. All survivor add-ons are fine tbh, but BNPs are probably the one I'd wanna see go

    4. I see scalped topknot more than the other dumb add-ons. Almost never see Tombstone piece, iri head, pinky finger etc

    5. Please just delete Haddonfield for the love of everything

    6. Map offerings needed to be removed years ago

    7. Dead hard, because dead hard for distance makes me lose brain cells whenever I see it

    8. Mindbreaker because it's OP. Nah, real answer would probably be bamboozle. Hate that brain-dead perk with a passion.

    I’d keep twins for oppression but otherwise agreed

  • QwQw QwQw

    @Phasmamain said:

    A dev walks up to you and says you have to remove one from each of these categories

    1. Survivor (Their teachable go too)
    2. Killer (Their teachables go too)
    3. Survivor addon
    4. Killer addon
    5. Map
    6. Offering(This can be one type of addon like luck offerings)
    7. Survivor perk
    8. Killer perk

    What would you choose? I’ll share my list

    1. Jake
    2. Nurse
    3. BNP
    4. Scalped Top Knot
    5. Midwich
    6. Luck offerings
    7. Hope
    8. Bamboozle
    1. Ace. All his teachable's suck, and not a lot of people play him.
    2. Twins. Not a lot of people play them, or even like them, and their perks suck.
    3. Brand New Part. Honestly, I don't really have much of a problem with survivor add-on's, but I had to pick one to get rid of it'd be this.
    4. Oni's Iri-Crest. The thing literally doesn't even do anything. Oni deserves a better add-on.
    5. Tie between Hawkins and Haddonfuck. Hawkins is more "balanced", but its just a pain in the ass to play on for both parties. Haddonfuck is just unbalanced as hell.
    6. Luck Offerings. No one uses them and they're outdated.
    7. Dead Hard without a doubt. ######### this perk.
    8. I'll pick one the many useless killer perks out of hat. Oh, looks we got Unrelenting.
  • KingFrost KingFrost


    1. Ace (Only because of his teachables being terrible)
    2. Deathslinger
    3. Brand New Part
    4. Iri Head
    5. Red Forest
    6. Strode Realty Key
    7. Resilience
    8. Monstrous Shrine
  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @QwQw said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/236778/question

    1. Ace. All his teachable's suck, and not a lot of people play him.
    2. Twins. Not a lot of people play them, or even like them, and their perks suck.
    3. Brand New Part. Honestly, I don't really have much of a problem with survivor add-on's, but I had to pick one to get rid of it'd be this.
    4. Oni's Iri-Crest. The thing literally doesn't even do anything. Oni deserves a better add-on.
    5. Tie between Hawkins and Haddonfuck. Hawkins is more "balanced", but its just a pain in the ass to play on for both parties. Haddonfuck is just unbalanced as hell.
    6. Luck Offerings. No one uses them and they're outdated.
    7. Dead Hard without a doubt. ######### this perk.
    8. I'll pick one the many useless killer perks out of hat. Oh, looks we got Unrelenting.

    Fair list I actually forgot about iri crest because of how bad it is

  • Jack_TheJolteon Jack_TheJolteon

    @Phasmamain said:

    A dev walks up to you and says you have to remove one from each of these categories

    1. Survivor (Their teachable go too)
    2. Killer (Their teachables go too)
    3. Survivor addon
    4. Killer addon
    5. Map
    6. Offering(This can be one type of addon like luck offerings)
    7. Survivor perk
    8. Killer perk

    What would you choose? I’ll share my list

    1. Jake
    2. Nurse
    3. BNP
    4. Scalped Top Knot
    5. Midwich
    6. Luck offerings
    7. Hope
    8. Bamboozle
    1. Feng
    2. Wraith
    3. Styptic Agent
    4. Iridescent Head
    5. Haddonfield
    6. Luck Offerings
    7. Buckle Up
    8. Monstrous Shrine
  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @KingFrost said:

    1. Ace (Only because of his teachables being terrible)
    2. Deathslinger
    3. Brand New Part
    4. Iri Head
    5. Red Forest
    6. Strode Realty Key
    7. Resilience
    8. Monstrous Shrine

    Out of curiosity why resilience?

  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @Jack_TheJolteon said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/236778/question

    1. Feng
    2. Wraith
    3. Styptic Agent
    4. Iridescent Head
    5. Haddonfield
    6. Luck Offerings
    7. Buckle Up
    8. Monstrous Shrine

    I agree wraiths perks are garbage but i really like his power on both sides

  • KingFrost KingFrost

    @Phasmamain said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2045442#Comment_2045442

    Out of curiosity why resilience?

    Survivors can heal up to 99, work on a gen, and the second they hear the terror radius, finish their heal. Kind of sucks they can get increased gen speed for limited risk.

  • REL1_C REL1_C
    1. Ace
    2. Spirit
    3. Blood Amber
    4. Iri Head
    5. Dead Dawg Saloon
    6. Map Offerings (That means all)
    7. OoO (Ah too late)
    8. NOED
  • HectorBrando HectorBrando
    1. Ash
    2. Twins
    3. Odd bulb
    4. Swing Chains
    5. Midwich
    6. Hatch offerings
    7. No Mither
    8. Insidious
  • Zixology Zixology
    1. Kate (worthless perks)
    2. Plague (most annoying killer to face who deletes stealth from the game and punishes existing)
    3. Iri Bulb (I don't like altering the blinding speed of flashlights because it messes up timing)
    4. Black Incense (if Plague was to remain in the game), Iri Head otherwise
    5. Hawkins (just fucc off with this map... I don't care what side I'm playing, I'll stand still and wait for it to be over)
    6. Hawkins map offering (again... fucc this map)
    7. Deja Vu (it sucks...)
    8. NOED (it rewards bad play and "do bones" isn't a good excuse when devs are putting these things inside boxes that are facing walls... ((Most new maps)) )
  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    @Zixology said:

    1. Kate (worthless perks)
    2. Plague (most annoying killer to face who deletes stealth from the game and punishes existing)
    3. Iri Bulb (I don't like altering the blinding speed of flashlights because it messes up timing)
    4. Black Incense (if Plague was to remain in the game), Iri Head otherwise
    5. Hawkins (just fucc off with this map... I don't care what side I'm playing, I'll stand still and wait for it to be over)
    6. Hawkins map offering (again... fucc this map)
    7. Deja Vu (it sucks...)
    8. NOED (it rewards bad play and "do bones" isn't a good excuse when devs are putting these things inside boxes that are facing walls... ((Most new maps)) )

    Iri bulb only affects blind duration not the time to blind

  • Zixology Zixology

    @Phasmamain said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/2045531#Comment_2045531

    Iri bulb only affects blind duration not the time to blind

    I literally don't touch flashlight addons that aren't batteries, so honestly, the rest can go.

Categories