Aside from spirit and freddy who is in most need of a rework.
For me its myers. He is just so boring to play as and against unless its scratched mirror. it doesnt even feel like he has a real power all he does is just walk around and look at people. Nothing for mobility or nothing in a chase. He just looks at people for a while then can instadown for a bit then looks at people again.
Comments
Pig.
They have so many drawbacks that they are borderline useless.
Spirits strongest add-ons put her on par with an addonless nurse. With add-ons, nurse is far better than any other killer(besides hag).
Spirit needs a rework because for the most part there is barely any sort of counterplay against her. "Predicting" where she goes is barely a counterplay.
Sorry, but I don't see many people saying Wraith needs his power tweaked (aside from the people who think Wraith is too strong).
You sneak up on people and uncloak. Your uncloak isn't always a guaranteed hit because survivors can utilize pallets and windows. Nothing about that 1v1 interaction seems boring.
Myers is the one most in need of a rework of all the killers.
Twin were fine before they start punishing killer for using them optimally now they want the player to camp with viktor the chamge feel like that
Those guys are fine as they are
Its Trickster that needs a rework or buffs next.
Spirit may not need reworked... Her power is unique and thematic since the DbD designers love it that way. But to say that she is fine is just wrong. She needs looked at in some way, and that shouldn't even be in question.
Agree. I like to play against nurse and hate playing against a spirit.
And it's not just you. In many games vs spirit people suicide on first hook. It's so frustrating to play vs her.
Legion and Ash Williams
Nurse. You just can't beat what she brings to the table with her noclipping ability. No other killer comes close to her level of power. Keep an aspect of teleportation to her power, but she needs a total rework.
Except that even then its not really a good reason. Even assuming Infinite T3 Myers with Tombstone, you need 3 people to do that. But even assuming that scenario:
Billy can bodyblock for instadowns.
Plague can bodyblock for full infection.
Bubba can bodyblock for instadowns.
Twins can trap multiple injured survivors in an area, ending the game.
Trapper can place a trap on you.
Ghostface can stalk you too.
Piggy can down and trap you with extremely dirty addons that are arguably more powerful as Tombstone, because at least Tombstone has counterplay by jumping in lockers where Pig's addons literally require you to be lucky.
Oni being able to bodyblock you while injured gets his power very easily.
So even in the worst case scenario, doesnt make sense. T3 myers isnt that hard to counterplay compared to some other killers as Myers cannot walk faster than 115%. The collision doesnt make sense.
I know Scott's arguments, luckily for me, Scott isnt the authority on killers. Myers is objectively worse than Legion, but he argues Myers is better. Legion at least can use his power to reduce distance and get easy downs, Myers is forced to close the distance by holding W. Legion can use perks to heavily support his power, Myers doesnt really have that. Legion can use his power to quickly traverse the map, Myers cant do anything near that.
Legion is fine. He is counterintuitive to play, but far from weak or bad.
Legion can't use his power for distance.
He gains no distance by doing that.
... You do realize he can run AND vault faster right? You close so much distance by simply using vaults to use a straight line as much as possible rather than snaking around obstacles, practically doubling the amount of distance you need to walk. Most maps arent open fields where all you can do is hold W. There are obstacles with vaults you can use. Being able to vault through windows. Not even including the fact that you reach objectives quicker before your power runs out, allowing you to get a Pop off where other killers would not.
But even assuming its a full straight lines, there are addons and perks that aid you in it for an increased speed or decreased fatique. Which Myers does not have access to. Let alone that if you hit a survivor before your power runs out, you can double the amount of time it takes before you get fatique, meaning even more distance without increasing fatique.
Just as you can use your power to get ahead of a survivor to bodyblock a pallet or window that would otherwise extend a chase, which he cant do if he just holds W, thus gaining distance.
But if you are going to assume Legion at his worst, I will use Myers at his worst:
You walk at 105% and can only get faster by reaching T2 which requires you to stalk a survivor. Meaning you cannot do #########. You dont have a lunge either so the only way to guarantee stalk is by brute forcing and stalk as long as you can. Excluding addons, just as you excluded addons for Legion.
I must remind you here, that Scott is defending Myers quite strongly, even though Legion at least can use his power a lot more beneficially than Myers.
Again, does Legion need slight addressing? Definitely. I dont think a missed or hit basic attack should reduce the time for his power.
I disagree,
I'll leave it at that.
Trapper. He's the second weakest killer in the game, only beat by Legion. Legion, however, at least doesn't need to cross the map for their power.
in case of this it is you that should provide data. you're the one that state spirit is fine while majority of player said isn't you're the one making statement. dont turn this into logical fallacy
Me not, Twins are one of the more interesting killers, and maybe one of the most versatile ones. I use Victor for scouting, chasing, defending a gen, there are many more ways to use the two than just slugging all. Only when I struggle really hard I may switch to some more slugging, but thats usually also enabled by survivors not healing.
Legion, Pig, Myers and Trickster.
Maybe if people would not suicide against spirit the survivor could have a chance. But in a early 3v1 no way survivor win that unless the play hide and seek all game and take all the time in the world to finish the gen
Trapper 100% his kit is so outdated and takes so much time. Myers also just to update him. If we are talking total overhaul probably Legion, just dont know what they would do
I feel like Trapper is the one in most dire need of a rework. He doesn't even have the bag as base kit.