Skip to content

In Spirit Of The Other Discussion: Which 10 Add-ons Do You Remove?

Boss Boss
in General Discussions

Here's the discussion i mean btw, thanks for the idea: https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/233096/you-can-only-keep-10


Sorry Survivor-only players, but this discussion ain't for you because...

Think of the Killer you like to play the most.

Now think of their complete Add-on arsenal.

Now remove your 10 least-liked Add-ons.

What do you have left?

Post your Killer of choice & your 10 chosen Add-ons!


Wraith (Keep in mind this is NOT 4.6.0 PTB Wraith!)
  • "Windstorm" - Blood, obvious why.
  • "Windstorm" - White, obvious why.
  • "Windstorm" - Mud, obvious why.
  • Coxcombed Clapper, obvious why.
  • "The Ghost" - Soot, to combine with either Clapper.
  • "Shadow Dance" - Blood, purely included for the Pallet build.
  • "Shadow Dance" - White, purely included for the Pallet build.
  • Bone Clapper, can make for some fun shenanigans with "The Ghost" - Soot.
  • "All Seeing" - Spirit, nice way to keep track if you feel lost.
  • "All Seeing" - Blood, i've spotted more Survivors in hiding with this than i initially thought i would.

Some things to mention...

  • "The Serpent" - Soot, "The Hound" - Soot, "The Beast" - Soot, "Blink" - Mud, "Blind Warrior" - Mud & "Blink" - White are all lol.
  • "Blind Warrior" - White is nice in general, but those ~+3 seconds per heal just aren't enough for me to put it up there.
  • The "Swift Hunt" series is also nice in general, but that max. of 0.6 seconds less cloak time also isn't enough for me to put it up there.
Tagged: Trusted

Comments

  • Adjatha Adjatha

    I'll do you one better: you can throw out every single Pyramid Head add on except the ones that extend the range of his shockwave. All the others, from the browns all the way up to the iridescents are atrociously awful, with as close to zero gameplay impact as any item in DBD.

  • TAG TAG

    Killer: The Pig

    Add-ons I'd keep:

    1) Combat Straps - Good for ambushing

    2) John's Medical File - Good for ambushing

    3) Video Tape - Good for ambushing

    4) Last Will - Extra RBT is always nice

    5) Jigsaw's Annotated Plan - Good for the Six Box Shuffle; Dece for Trap stall

    6) Bag of Gears - ONLY marginally useful with Crate of Gears; if it weren't for that, I'd say toss it

    7) Jigsaw's Sketch - Dece for Trap stall and/or Trap kills

    8) Crate of Gears - Good for Trap stall, Trap kills, and catching a Survivor at a box

    9) Tampered Timer - Bad do-nothing add-on, but I LURV me some Trap kills

    10) Uh...Rules Set No. 2? I genuinely can't think of a 10th add-on I'd be happy with keeping. The rest all are mostly trash. I do enjoy Trap Kills, and I GUEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEESS RSN2 TECHINCALLY enables that, though I still don't like the add-on.

  • Boss Boss

    @Adjatha said:

    I'll do you one better: you can throw out every single Pyramid Head add on except the ones that extend the range of his shockwave. All the others, from the browns all the way up to the iridescents are atrociously awful, with as close to zero gameplay impact as any item in DBD.

    Then go make that discussion. 🙂

  • GoodBoyKaru GoodBoyKaru

    Well considering I play Pyramid Head the most, here we go:

    • Iridescent Seal of Metatron- effect is good for nothing but tunneling someone haha
    • Crimson Ceremony Book- bloodweb clutter. Who likes hemmorhage?!
    • Lost Memories Book- bloodweb clutter. Who likes oblivious?!
    • Rust-Coloured Egg- bloodweb clutter. Who likes blindness?!
    • Scarlet Egg- bloodweb clutter.
    • Misty Day, Remains of Judgement- useless.
    • Leopard-Print Fabric- useless.
    • Copper Ring- 0.5 seconds extra is awful.
    • Lead Ring- beyond useless.
    • Spearhead- 1 second extra is awful.
  • Todgeweiht Todgeweiht

    I play demo and deathslinger almost on par

    For Demo, it's not too hard:

    • Red Moss - It's #########, the increased undetectable is not worth the trade off of having increased recovery cooldown
    • Vermilion webcap - The increased undetectable is overall pretty useless, if you want a stealth build for demo run tinkerer and call it a day
    • Violet waxcap - Same as above
    • Brass case lighter - useless, blindness is too situational
    • Lifeguard whistle - it's bad, 5 seconds is basically nothing
    • barb's glasses- never use it
    • eleven's soda - never use it
    • unknown egg - never use it
    • viscous webbing - never use it
    • Sticky lining - never use it

    (to be honest the only add-ons I use for demo are rat liver and rat tail)

    For deathslinger, neither:

    • Rickety chains - meme add-on, would not miss it
    • Bayshore cigar - somewhat situational, you don't want to be stunned unless you want to save some STBFL stacks.
    • Chewing tobacco - Same as above
    • Honey locust stone - Same as above, gets massively outclassed by rusted spike
    • Wanted poster - I don't even aim most of the time, any good deathslinger player quickscopes. No point on bringing this add-on.
    • Jaw smasher- same as above
    • Gold creek whiskey - It's fun but really useless, I used it a lot on rank reset with marshal's bag and M&A and the amount of people I catched off guard, especially on indoor maps, was really, really funny.
    • marshal's bag - same as above
    • Bayshore's gold tooth - I personally find this add-on fun, but I have learnt it's not really useful. I equip it as a lucky charm most of the time.
    • Snake Oil - Same as above.
  • MrDardon MrDardon

    I main PH but is there any reason to keep any of his Add-Ons? All except the range add-ons are awful, and people say Demo has bad Add-ons.

    I'll go with my ex-main who is Myers:

    10 Add-ons I'd keep:

    1. Judith's Tombstone

    2. Fragrant Tuft of Hair

    3. Scratched Mirror

    4. Tombstone Piece

    5. Hair Bow

    6. J. Myers Memorial

    7. Judith's Journal

    8. Mirror Shard

    9. Memorial Flower

    10. Boyfriend's Memo


    The others are close to being on my list like:

    - Dead Rabbit

    Oh it's only this one actually, following can go into my trashcan:

    - Blond Hair, Tacky Earrings, Reflective Fragment, Glass Fragment, Jewerely, Hair Brush, Jewerely Box, Lock of Hair.... and especially this waste of 6k Bloodpoints


    ----====Vanity Mirror====----

  • SnakeSound222 SnakeSound222

    Wait, is this 10 add-ons we keep or the 10 we remove? I see people posting both.

  • Mister_Holdout Mister_Holdout

    Twins player here.

    None of their add-ons are all that great. I usually just play without add-ons.

    If I had to remove 10: Baby Teeth, Weighty Rattle, Sewer Sludge, Rusted Needle, Victor's Soldier, Iridescent Pendent, Silencing Cloth, Cat's Eye, Cat Figurine, and Drop of Perfume.

  • Boss Boss

    @SnakeSound222 said:

    Wait, is this 10 add-ons we keep or the 10 we remove? I see people posting both.

    You can do both if you want, it doesn't matter much.

  • GingerBeard GingerBeard

    I couldn't decide between Clown or Blight so chose both. I guess I should clarify this is what I would keep to avoid confusion.

    Clown:

    1. Cheap Gin Bottle
    2. Cigar Box
    3. Ether 15%
    4. Garish Make-up Kit
    5. Bottle of Chloroform
    6. Flask of Bleach
    7. Sulphuric Acid Vial
    8. Solvent Jug
    9. Sticky Soda Bottle
    10. Fingerless Parade Gloves

    Blight:

    1. Compound Thirty-Three
    2. Alchemist's Ring
    3. Soul Chemical
    4. Vigo's Journal
    5. Blighted Crow
    6. Compound Twenty-One
    7. Umbra Salts
    8. Blighted Rat
    9. Canker Thorn
    10. Plague Bile


  • Phasmamain Phasmamain

    Clown

    1. Redheads pinky finger
    2. Tattoo’s middle finger
    3. Kerosene can
    4. Sulphiric acid vial
    5. vhs porn
    6. Party bottles
    7. Robin feather
    8. Starling feather
    9. Solvent jug
    10. Thick cork stopper
  • IamFran IamFran

    Any addon which gives the killer the ability to one hit a non injurerd survivor, too unfair and depeding on my mood they usually mean "suicide in first hook" to me except Iridiscent Pendant.

    Iridiscent head, Redhead's pinky finger, Iridiscent coin.

  • TheHunter2529 TheHunter2529

    I'll do billy

    10 addons to remove

    . Big Buckle

    . Black Grease

    . Tuned Carburettor

    . Leafy Mash

    . Mother's Helpers

    . Death Engravings

    . Speed Limiter

    . Doom Engravings

    . Off Brand motor oil

    . Apex muffler

  • malatruse malatruse

    For the Pig, I'd keep:

    • Combat Straps (her best addon)
    • Video Tape
    • Last Will
    • Face Mask (for map users)
    • Bag of Gears
    • Tampered Timer
    • Crate of Gears
    • Jigsaw's Sketch
    • Amanda's Secret
    • Rules Set No. 2

    The rest can go. The addons that increase skill check chances at boxes are actually worse than nothing against good survivors. Traps causing hemorrhage or mangled are pretty useless as well since you usually won't be chasing the survivor wearing it. Amanda's Letter is just...such a niche addon unless you don't plan on using your RBTs.

    For Trapper:

    • Padded Jaws (for the memes)
    • Trapper Bag
    • Logwood Dye
    • Tar Bottle
    • Setting Tools
    • Stitched Bag
    • Honing Stone
    • Fastening Tools
    • Iridescent Stone
    • Bloody Coil

    I don't think I ever use anything not on this list.

Categories