Who is supposed to win under perfect circumstances? (POLL)
If all 4 survivors AND the killer play completely optimally and make absolutely no bad decisions throughout the game then who's supposed to win in your opinion (and why)?
Definition of winning in this scenario:
Killer: 3 or 4 kills
Survivors: 3 or 4 escapes
Comments
2 survive, 2 die.
The thing is, the line between all escape, all die and 2 die/escape is sometimes super thin because the endgame is bad designed.
I'd say neither. Under perfect conditions it would be a 2k.
Anyone thinking the killer is winning that scenario even remotely unless it's a nurse is delusional. It isn't even a close call.
Always survivors, no matter what other people say or think, it's a fact.
When a killer plays perfectly is because he is punishing survivors making mistakes (unless you are Nurse), if survivors dont make mistakes there is no perfect play for the killer, simple as that.
Gen Rush shortens the amount of times the killer could punish a survivor.
The Entity wins.
in b4 "I 4k everytime guise"
With perfect play Survivors absolutely crush killers, it isn't even a contest.
The only exception to this is Nurse, who is Nurse.
BHVR wins either way
Everyone who plays for fun and not to min max grind bp wins.
Obviously only 4k is acceptable
But I do as Spirit ;-; I love her to death!
There are too many variables for this to have a concrete answer. For example it depends on Survivors (are they all Claudette’s who can hide easily or are they bright blonde Kate’s or Purple hair Fengs).
Map also plays a big factor (from Coldwind Farm to The Game).
Also depends on WHICH killer the host decides to play as (Nurse or Freddy for example).
Assuming they all bring their best add-ons, there are still TOO MANY variables. Don’t feel so bummed out though if you don’t have an actual answer, that’s why this game is so great in the first place.
The best answer. Killers and survivors are both pawns to the Entity.
If killer is having a perfect game then the pressure should be to much for survivors to perform optimally. Same is true in reverse, killer can't win if survivors are pulling perfect chases and zero skill failures. The whole power structure depends one one side banking on the other's mistakes. But in the current version survivors have the upper hand if its a perfect run through for them, not alot killers can do if their only info is gens popping.
2 escapes and 2 kills
It’s a draw.