My Tier List

SCP_FOR_DBD

Pretty self explanatory. I'd be happy to debate it. Left to right is power. I could potentially see a few moving but I think this is pretty accurate.

zoozoom6

@SCP_FOR_DBD said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1521758#Comment_1521758

Nah, demogorgon can get to places faster and is undetectable, billy is so loud the entire map can hear him. Holding shred can force survivors into bad situations. Say a survivor is going in a line to a pallet, hold shred and they have to move or get hit, now they're in a worse position you cancel shred and hit them anyway. Rat liver is so good because it makes demo move faster while shredding, with it being a brown it might as well be base kit. And once again, placing 2 portals basically ensures that a survivor cannot cleanse a portal without getting hit or needing a second person. Factor in how Billy can be useless on some maps and he gets held back.

its super easy to make his chainsaw silent post rework if that what your refering to but he is the fastest killer in the game bar hag. billy always has a 1 hit ability he is not useless anywhere but his map control can vary alot on diffrent maps

SCP_FOR_DBD

@zoozoom6 said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1521844#Comment_1521844

its super easy to make his chainsaw silent post rework if that what your refering to but he is the fastest killer in the game bar hag. billy always has a 1 hit ability he is not useless anywhere but his map control can vary alot on diffrent maps

Thats the thing, hes super inconsistent, his map traversal and control can either be some of the best or worse in the game depending on the map, Demos is always better than average. Billy is consistently better in a chase though, hence both being mid tier. As for silent saw, your either using his yellow which barely does anything, or your using his Iri, which can be countered by SWF and is his Iri, not his base kit.

SCP_FOR_DBD

@xEa said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1521854#Comment_1521854

It is true that mistakes can be very punishing as nurse, but i had in mind that a really good nurse is simply not making those mistakes which you experience against those really good nurse players every once in a while.

Billy is like i said still more or less the same and a strong billy (i faced a couple) shows his potential and how good he can be in the right hands.

Against Plague its really easy to win. Just dont cleanse, and if you do use a fountain thats in an era where Plague gets no benefit. She is kinda like the Legion over time, gets easy first hits, but then she has no real power. It all comes down how survivors play and if they play correct, she is relativly hopeless. She might be even one of the worst killer imho.

Demo for me personally struggels to much at many tiles and his ability to port is compared to freddys port a bit weak.

I don't see enough nurses that don't make mistakes like that to not factor in mistakes yknow? And while Billy can certainly be a terror, his inconsistency with maps made him kinda a gamble, his addons being destroyed took him from an A to a B imo. And Plague has great snowball potential, can't heal if they're already downed. And theres rarely a spot in which I can't get some use out of CP. Demos essentially just a slightly better m1 killer at tiles, and while his Teleport isn't the best its certainly no slouch. Hence mid tier.

zoozoom6

@SCP_FOR_DBD said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1521894#Comment_1521894

Thats the thing, hes super inconsistent, his map traversal and control can either be some of the best or worse in the game depending on the map, Demos is always better than average. Billy is consistently better in a chase though, hence both being mid tier. As for silent saw, your either using his yellow which barely does anything, or your using his Iri, which can be countered by SWF and is his Iri, not his base kit.

i wouldnt call billy inconsistant while trapper, pig,huntress,wraith and hag exist in their current form. i couldve sworn one of the new addons made the saw silent when billy was undetectable i think it was a yellow idk if they made it basekit or deleted it but i dont see it anymore

Star99er

I'd switch Pyramid head with Billy, Billy is still a great killer after the nerfs. Myers and Clown aren't that bad either, I don't think any killer is currently D-Tier besides maybe Wraith.

SCP_FOR_DBD

@zoozoom6 said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1521944#Comment_1521944

i wouldnt call billy inconsistant while trapper, pig,huntress,wraith and hag exist in their current form. i couldve sworn one of the new addons made the saw silent when billy was undetectable i think it was a yellow idk if they made it basekit or deleted it but i dont see it anymore

He kinda is as inconsistent as them though, maps being such a massive factor for his rank.

EnderloganYT

I'd bring Myers and GF up a tier each, but that's just my personal preference. other than that, yeah I pretty much agree.

SCP_FOR_DBD

@Star99er said:

I'd switch Pyramid head with Billy, Billy is still a great killer after the nerfs. Myers and Clown aren't that bad either, I don't think any killer is currently D-Tier besides maybe Wraith.

Thanks you for your thoughts, I put billy in High B cause his addons suck and hes pretty map dependant. Myers takes tons of setup for a reward that isn't all that better than other killers unless your running addons, in which case the setup is even longer. And while Clown does have the unique ability to send survivors in certain places in a chase, he doesn't have much else. PH is mid A because he can ignore meta perks, save time with cages and judgment, and punishment allows for amazing mind games and cheeky hits.