Please Revert Thana Back as Mangled and healing slowdown already have limited time

I cant play ghost face with Nurse calling and Thana combo at all because of the nerf.

I needs my hit and run, spread pressure play

How can one perks basically only work for Legion. You already nerfed all Mangle effect

Comments

  • Mangled never should have been changed to affect healing progress in the first place, all it does is kill off any non meta healing perks. When was the last time you saw someone run reactive healing, resurgence, or solidarity?

  • @Sarrif said:

    Mangled never should have been changed to affect healing progress in the first place, all it does is kill off any non meta healing perks. When was the last time you saw someone run reactive healing, resurgence, or solidarity?

    That is a fault of Hemorrage, not Mangled.

    All Mangled does is give you a bit longer heal.

    Hemorrage makes it so you lose healing progress.

    I would be rather if Hemorrage was timed and Mangled wasn't

  • @SoGo said:

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/3702310#Comment_3702310

    That is a fault of Hemorrage, not Mangled.

    All Mangled does is give you a bit longer heal.

    Hemorrage makes it so you lose healing progress.

    I would be rather if Hemorrage was timed and Mangled wasn't

    The last complaint was heal take too much time not hemo where people can go hide and heal safely.

    August Update way back after all perk shake up was people stack up mangle and thana and pentimento thing and people was complaining.

  • So I can speak both from a Survivor standpoint and a killer standpoint as a main killer but I play Survivor a lot because I do it with my friends. And the one thing I will say is I absolutely agree Santa needs to be on nerfed because it feels really ######### that there is a perk that only works on two killers in the entire game and the two killers that can use it usually won't because there are better things they could be running. I was not fortunate enough to be around during the Santa 5% time but as a Survivor now the only time I ever pay any attention to thanatophobia is when all four survivors are injured hooked or dying and which point you just heal one of them and congratulations that's 14% removed from the Slowdown. And with how many people I see running deja vu or resilience that 6% slowdown is completely negated or just not super relevant cuz now they're just repairing it normal speed.

  • weird how they revert decisive strike but don't revert thana for killer.

  • This content has been removed.
  • This content has been removed.
  • @vBlossom_ said:

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/411303/please-revert-thana-back-as-mangled-and-healing-slowdown-already-have-limited-time

    No, it shouldn't be reverted, as killers got +10 seconds to gen time (gen takes 12% longer time basekit, basically) and nerf to medkits and healing at all:

    • Longer healings - healing took 16 seconds, now 24 seconds,
    • All medkit give one self-heal,
    • Bothany reworked into not synergizing with medkit,
    • CoH nerfed to not allow self-heal

    Why do you think it would be good to easily give -5.5% penalty per injured/dying survivor?

    I don't think, given above changes, that killers should have another easy-value perk next to PainRes / Pop / Lethal / NTH / Grim.

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/3702694#Comment_3702694

    So DS going from 3 seconds to 5 seconds would balance making Thana much more oppressive in current state of the game?
    I don't think so.

    i just want a -4% healing penalty per injured survivor back. in current numbers, it would be 5%.

    with the nerf of sloppy, exposed type builds are impossible to play as on killer. expose perks suck too much. they're either hexes which are worthless or timed effects like dragon grip, myc, hubris etc. Sloppy was only good expose-type perk. It prevents people from healing so all your future chases were 1 hit downs.

    So DS going from 3 seconds to 5 seconds

    DS is slowing killer down passively for no effort.

  • Thana encouraged hits on multiple players (Is hit and run not healthy gameplay?) and provided slowdown via healing (Not another gen regression perk).

    If people wanted variety in Killer builds and spreading of pressure, reverting Thana would be an incentive to do so

  • This content has been removed.
  • Thana just needs frontloaded with a slight max nerf so it's useful on more than 2 killers. 4% 6% 3% 2% seems like a good balance while reducing it's max potential.

  • @Devil_hit11 said:

    weird how they revert decisive strike but don't revert thana for killer.

    ds is practically the same since the new animation takes so long. I think its about 3.7 seconds now.

  • Thana does need to be reverted back to its last version. This current version is terrible, even on its best killers.

  • @vBlossom_ said:

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/3702829#Comment_3702829

    I don't think people would want to verse killer with PainRes, Pop and Thana on top of it.

    Also in current state Thana incentivises hit and run playstyle - all survivors need to be injured for full value.

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/3702824#Comment_3702824

    i just want a -4% healing penalty per injured survivor back.

    But why? As I've mentioned above, healing perks got nerfed, medkits got nerfed, healing times are longer, yet you still want additional healing penalty on top of that?

    Like, don't you think that mangled, even timed-out, isn't enough at this point? After you hit someone with sloppy, they are healing slower, there are less healing perks and healing time got longer?

    https://us.v-cdn.net/6030815/uploads/062EEXF9C2H8/image.png

    If you put it on perspective, it looks like killers have semi-thana in basekit, back then it was 16 seconds per heal, now it's 24.

    "I don't think people would want to verse killer with PainRes, Pop and Thana on top of it."

    can you clarify this to me? I feel like you dont even understand how thana usage is?

    Does "PainRes, Pop and Thana" stronger or more oppressive than current slow down meta combo now, I cant magine man holy!

    so these are gabage combo then, below
    Pain + Pop + Grim

    Pain + Pop + DMS
    Pain + Pop + Corrupt Intervene
    Pain + Pop + Deadlock

    stacking slowdown will continue no matter what.

    Thana is the single core component of hit and run built

    Thana + Nurse calling +SBFL + Rapid

    Thana + Nurse calling +Jolt + Infectiours Fright


    Thana + Nurse calling + Jolt + Pop maybe

    Thana + Nurse + dying light + Pop

  • @caligraph said:

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/3702694#Comment_3702694

    ds is practically the same since the new animation takes so long. I think its about 3.7 seconds now.

    it is not the same at all. it was 1.4 seconds. now it is 3.7. that's crazy for m1 killer catch-up. it is back to being a 20 second-waste time button hold-w for killers.

  • Thana is a really ehh perk right now, getting 4 injuries is really good, however the fact that it gets shut down by one person healing sucks. honestly if there were to buff it, here is how they should do it. (Warning tokens)

    Thantophobia

    For each currently injured, downed, or hooked survivor gain a token up to 4

    once you have 4 tokens Thantophobia activates for 60 seconds. While you have 4 tokens the timer pauses.

    While activated survivors suffer from a 8/12/16 % Speed penalty for…

    • Repairing
    • Sabotaging
    • Cleansing
    • Blessing
  • @Devil_hit11 said:

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/3703004#Comment_3703004

    it is not the same at all. it was 1.4 seconds. now it is 3.7. that's crazy for m1 killer catch-up. it is back to being a 20 second-waste time button hold-w for killers.

    this just in- stun animation removed and ds fully meta again

  • @vBlossom_ said:

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/3702829#Comment_3702829

    I don't think people would want to verse killer with PainRes, Pop and Thana on top of it.

    Also in current state Thana incentivises hit and run playstyle - all survivors need to be injured for full value.

    https://forums.bhvr.com/dead-by-daylight/discussion/comment/3702824#Comment_3702824

    i just want a -4% healing penalty per injured survivor back.

    But why? As I've mentioned above, healing perks got nerfed, medkits got nerfed, healing times are longer, yet you still want additional healing penalty on top of that?

    Like, don't you think that mangled, even timed-out, isn't enough at this point? After you hit someone with sloppy, they are healing slower, there are less healing perks and healing time got longer?

    https://us.v-cdn.net/6030815/uploads/062EEXF9C2H8/image.png

    If you put it on perspective, it looks like killers have semi-thana in basekit, back then it was 16 seconds per heal, now it's 24.

    Like, don't you think that mangled, even timed-out, isn't enough at this point? After you hit someone with sloppy, they are healing slower, there are less healing perks and healing time got longer?

    the expose perks are too unreliable. I rather run sloppy+old thana and ensure my opponent is injured the entire trial.