My tier list for all you plunderin' hoarders

notameatybassriff98

and yes i included event stuff but i forgot the 4th anniversary items, which would be in the amazing category

p.s. this is based on item alone, not addons or perks

CashelP14

I have a lot on this I'd change lol

1. Alex Toolbox should top.
2. Green flashlight should be 2nd from top.
3. Commodious should be 2nd from top.
4. Green map should be 2nd from bottom.
5. Rainbow map should be top.
6. Purple key should be second from top.
7. Ranger Medkit should be top.

TripleSteal

@CashelP14 said:

I have a lot on this I'd change lol

1. Alex Toolbox should top.
2. Green flashlight should be 2nd from top.
3. Commodious should be 2nd from top.
4. Green map should be 2nd from bottom.
5. Rainbow map should be top.
6. Purple key should be second from top.
7. Ranger Medkit should be top.

Why do you allocate pink and purple keys into different tiers?

notameatybassriff98

@CashelP14 said:

I have a lot on this I'd change lol

1. Alex Toolbox should top.
2. Green flashlight should be 2nd from top.
3. Commodious should be 2nd from top.
4. Green map should be 2nd from bottom.
5. Rainbow map should be top.
6. Purple key should be second from top.
7. Ranger Medkit should be top.

1. Alex's is very useless and only good on a sabo build
2. yellow and green beemer's basically are the same just a smaller consumption rate
3. commodious is the only toolbox thats viable rn
4. green and pink maps basically are both useful but not amazing
5. ^
6. purple and pink keys do the same thing
7. ranger medkits give you only two heals without addons or sc
8. i made this as how good the items are by themselves and without addons or perks
9. also just because its ultra rare doesnt mean its amazing

CashelP14

@TripleSteal said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1737103#Comment_1737103

Why do you allocate pink and purple keys into different tiers?

@notameatybassriff98 said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1737103#Comment_1737103

both keys do the same thing, ask any dbd player and theyll tell you how bad alex's is, both maps are good, i put ranger second because it only gives you two heals with no addons or sc, both green and yellow flashlights both are technically the same, and this wasn't made based on rarity but how useful it is. Also commodius was the only toolbox that is viable rn

Fair enough with your reasoning. My reasoning is different due because of the potential perks and add-ons. I'm basing my picks off what I want to take out of the trial with me.

Alex's Toolbox: It's only good for sabo builds but it's extremely good at them. I like to run sabo builds from time to time so I find it more important to keep.

Flashlights: There is very little difference in them true. Tbh I'd actually probably move them both up to 2nd. They're very important and probably my favourite items to get from a chest.

Commodious: It's a good toolbox but not something I'd take over the other items I listed. It isn't the fastest for gens and not the best for sabo either.

Maps: A green map only tracks gens without add-ons which imo makes it pretty low on my list of things to take from the trial. Rainbow however can help find totems, exits and hatch.

Keys: Yea I understand your reasoning. Mines is that if I took it from a chest would I keep the purple one over the items I placed above it? No. In terms of items that are useful when looted it could be one of the best.

Ranger Medkits: Still the best in the game.

I'd say you should mention in your top post that this is based off no add-on or perks working with the item.

MadLordJack

Personally I prefer yellow medkits to green ones. I like the extra charges.