In a battle royale, which killer would win?

bubbabrotha

I think bubba.

SloppyKnockout

Any answer other than Oni is incorrect.

Respectfulnancymain

Demo

Zeus

Wraith. Just go afk all game

AVoiceOfReason

Nurse. She'd wack you then teleport away, waiting to strike again.

Hoodied

Pyramid Head, definitely him as bullets couldn’t stop him and in the near end of Silent Hill, you didn’t even kill the Pyramid Heads, they actually used their own weapons against themselves.

If anything, Michael and Pyramid Head will have a fun fight

Antares2332

@bubbabrotha said:

I think bubba.

I think we do a pretty good job so far

Funguu

I'm pretty sure Freddy Krueger would win, I'm 99% sure he is immortal and the man controls his own dimension

BigBrainMegMain

Michael, Pyramid Head and Oni.

SloppyKnockout

@Funguu said:

I'm pretty sure Freddy Krueger would win, I'm 99% sure he is immortal and the man controls his own dimension

I mean, a lot of the killers in DBD seem to be immortal. Immortality doesn't mean much lol

Funguu

@SloppyKnockout said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1460025#Comment_1460025

I mean, a lot of the killers in DBD seem to be immortal. Immortality doesn't mean much lol

The non immortal's until proven immortal - Trapper, Wraith, Billy, Hag, Nurse, Huntress, Doctor, Bubba, Pig, Clown, Legion, Plague, Ghost Face, Demo

The immortals - Freddy, Spirit, Pyramid Head

Not very clear/unsure - Oni, Deathslinger, Micheal Myers

Lol nah

whammigobambam

Nea because she can just hold m1 on a generator.

MrLimonka

@whammigobambam said:

Nea because she can just hold m1 on a generator.

Exactly, nea starts gen-rushing with Brand New Parts which causes all the other killers to DC, leaving her to win

Kolonite

Micheal. He is evil incarnate.

Sinister0208

@Funguu said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1460126#Comment_1460126

The non immortal's until proven immortal - Trapper, Wraith, Billy, Hag, Nurse, Huntress, Doctor, Bubba, Pig, Clown, Legion, Plague, Ghost Face, Demo

The immortals - Freddy, Spirit, Pyramid Head

Not very clear/unsure - Oni, Deathslinger, Micheal Myers

Lol nah

The immortals - Freddy, Spirit, Pyramid Head, Micheal Myers (also).

This.

Karaage

Maybe not realistic, but I'm rooting for Legion. With all the Killers stuck together in one place, You could just be running in Frenzy all the time. Eventually they'd bleed out, no?

GreenPufferFish

nea

ClickyClicky

Billy since he’s the most OP

VonCrow

Claudette would win, with the survivor's rulebook for killers.

WatchBloodRain

@Jessymay321 said:

Short answer. It would be a never ending tie between the spirit and the nurse.

long answer.

The clown would die first, he’s out of shape likely has cancer fat, slow uses a pocket knife.

The trapper is also out, his power is next to useless in this fight and though he is strong he has no stealth and would be outclassed in combat skills by the hillbilly leatherface Mikey and the oni.

The wraith could potentially hide forever but if we were to assume he engages in combat his bell would give away his stealth and he himself is scrawny and fairly week with a off balance, clumsy weapon and no combat experience. He would most likely be picked off early by the legion swarm as they would see him as an easy target.

The legion would make it decently far into the fight being the only team of killers. Even so they are just kids with knives and after picking off the clown, wraith and Freddy they would be outclassed by the remaining killers and forced into hit and run tactics. Eventually the nurse, spirit and hillbilly would take them down.

freddy would be dead in seconds. We can assume the fight takes place in the entity’s realm and not Freddie’s realm so Freddy is just a middle aged man with a knife glove and no longer immortal.

Leather face would be singled out and killed by the hillbilly early in the fight. The hillbilly has very low intelligence and would see leather faces chainsaw as a threat. So being a stronger faster leather face the fight would be very sided. Dead leather face.

the pig. Useless power mid 20s woman with a crap weapon. Dead

ghost face. Useless power. Mid 20s man with a crap weapon. Dead

the plague slightly annoying power mid 30s woman with a laughable weapon. Dead.

hillbilly after killing leatherface the hillbilly would likely turn his attention to the Demigorgon. He would see it not understand what is it and want it to die. After that he could probably chase down a few of the legion before dying to the oni, Mikey, or PH.

The hag she’s a slow week disfigured child. She dies seconds after the clown does.

Demogrogon. They really aren’t that hard to kill and are only marginally stronger than humans. He’s out pretty quick.

the huntress I wouldn’t expect much from her yes she’s strong yes she has throwing hatches but she’s outclassed in strength and speed by half the roster. She’s dead.

Death slinger. Old man, spear gun slow. Dead.

the doctor. His shocks would be nothing more than an annoyance and in the end he is just a middle aged man with a stick. Dead.

Mikey Oni and PH

when most of the roster is dead outside of the spirit and nurse these three

Would be facing off in an epic 3 way clash of titans which Mikey would win. While both the oni and PH can take a beating Mikey not only likely being the strongest of all killers has his healing factor. He would win the war of Attrition.

sprit nurse

they would spend the entire fight hitting and running taking shots for sure but here’s the problem they are ghosts. They can’t be killed. So once Mikey is standing on the pile of broken bodies they would eventually pick him apart and end in a stalemate.

Props to the amount of effort put into this quite impressive

MegaWaffle

@SloppyKnockout said:

Any answer other than Oni is incorrect.

Wrong.

It would be Myers.

Just like any Battle Royal the person who often wins is the one who hides the whole game and only goes after people who are injured (third party).

MegaWaffle

@bubbabrotha said:

I think bubba.

Bubba lost to a teenage girl who escaped capture.

GhostMaceNotCrusty

Gotta say ph, as seen in sh2 the only thing that can kill him is him

bubbabrotha

@MegaWaffle said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/173453/in-a-battle-royale-which-killer-would-win

Bubba lost to a teenage girl who escaped capture.

I mean his power. A chainsaw is more powerful than half of the roster.

DaddyPyramidHead

Ph, Oni, Freddy, and depending on the Version of Mikey.

Dwight_Fairfield

Michael Myers of course. You can shoot him, stab him, set him on fire.......evil won't die. He'll just keep going.

Pandamonium

While all killers have some sort of experience of killing prior to being taken by the entity, the huntress is one of the only one who actually has combat experience I believe, defeating armed men by herself in the Russian forests.

The oni also has combat experience as his lore delineates that he has travelled through Japan, slaughtering both farmers and some of the most experienced and fiercest warriors.

And then we have spirit and nurse. Rin has the better weapon, while nurse has the better potential to catch someone out and eliminate them. While you can argue that they are both ghosts and thus, physical weapons can't kill them, they can still interact and be hurt by physical items such as pallets or sharp objects such as from decisive strike. So I think they can last, but not win.

The legion is a group of teenagers who run very quickly and like to stab. I'd like to see those knives penetrate Oni's armor or Pyramid head's, well, pyramid.

Danny and Pig both rely on stealth, which gives them the edge in getting the first hit, but after that, they are ordinary people wielding knives like legion.

Both billy and bubba have some menacing weapons to use against their opponents, a hammer and a chainsaw. I'd see them as more resilient than ordinary people, but bubba is outplayed due to his lower level of intelligence, thus making him more vulnerable to battle hardened hunters who use sophisticated tactics to survive and kill. Billy can be very impressive, being a larger threat than bubba in terms of offensive combat, but I just can't see him winning against Oni and pyramid head in a head on fight, or huntress when she has a distance advantage and perhaps high ground, or demogorgon.

So I'm thinking Oni or huntress, and although I'm rooting for huntress, Oni would probably win against her.

Schmierbach

I'm pretty sure Oni would win. He's one of the strongest of the killers, one of the fastest, by far the most experienced, and loves to bathe in the blood of the wounded to enhance his power which there would be blood everywhere during this.

PH and Myers while extremely high on endurance and strength are both reletively slow and have no technique. I think they could both be KOed by a Blood Fueled Oni but not killed considering they can't die.

Demogorgon would be blitzed being simply a large animal with no armor. It could give him trouble if it got a jump on him, but his katana would easily severe its limbs with no armor.

For Freddy it depends how powerful the Entity allows him to be. Its essentially Demon vs Demon though and Freddy's claws are not as threatening as Oni's Katana or Kanbo. In the dream Freddy toys with Oni forever. In the real world Oni stomps hard.

Oni MAY be one of the few killers that could blitz Spirit or Nurse while they are fatigued as well.

Everyone else in the roster either gets blitzed, loses due to the Oni's experience as a samurai, or are already killed off and fueling his blood craze.

MegaWaffle

@bubbabrotha said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1461005#Comment_1461005

I mean his power. A chainsaw is more powerful than half of the roster.

Not if it overheats.

👈️👈️

xEa

@Jessymay321 said:

Short answer. It would be a never ending tie between the spirit and the nurse.

long answer.

The clown would die first, he’s out of shape likely has cancer fat, slow uses a pocket knife.

The trapper is also out, his power is next to useless in this fight and though he is strong he has no stealth and would be outclassed in combat skills by the hillbilly leatherface Mikey and the oni.

The wraith could potentially hide forever but if we were to assume he engages in combat his bell would give away his stealth and he himself is scrawny and fairly week with a off balance, clumsy weapon and no combat experience. He would most likely be picked off early by the legion swarm as they would see him as an easy target.

The legion would make it decently far into the fight being the only team of killers. Even so they are just kids with knives and after picking off the clown, wraith and Freddy they would be outclassed by the remaining killers and forced into hit and run tactics. Eventually the nurse, spirit and hillbilly would take them down.

freddy would be dead in seconds. We can assume the fight takes place in the entity’s realm and not Freddie’s realm so Freddy is just a middle aged man with a knife glove and no longer immortal.

Leather face would be singled out and killed by the hillbilly early in the fight. The hillbilly has very low intelligence and would see leather faces chainsaw as a threat. So being a stronger faster leather face the fight would be very sided. Dead leather face.

the pig. Useless power mid 20s woman with a crap weapon. Dead

ghost face. Useless power. Mid 20s man with a crap weapon. Dead

the plague slightly annoying power mid 30s woman with a laughable weapon. Dead.

hillbilly after killing leatherface the hillbilly would likely turn his attention to the Demigorgon. He would see it not understand what is it and want it to die. After that he could probably chase down a few of the legion before dying to the oni, Mikey, or PH.

The hag she’s a slow week disfigured child. She dies seconds after the clown does.

Demogrogon. They really aren’t that hard to kill and are only marginally stronger than humans. He’s out pretty quick.

the huntress I wouldn’t expect much from her yes she’s strong yes she has throwing hatches but she’s outclassed in strength and speed by half the roster. She’s dead.

Death slinger. Old man, spear gun slow. Dead.

the doctor. His shocks would be nothing more than an annoyance and in the end he is just a middle aged man with a stick. Dead.

Mikey Oni and PH

when most of the roster is dead outside of the spirit and nurse these three

Would be facing off in an epic 3 way clash of titans which Mikey would win. While both the oni and PH can take a beating Mikey not only likely being the strongest of all killers has his healing factor. He would win the war of Attrition.

sprit nurse

they would spend the entire fight hitting and running taking shots for sure but here’s the problem they are ghosts. They can’t be killed. So once Mikey is standing on the pile of broken bodies they would eventually pick him apart and end in a stalemate.

freddy would be dead in seconds. We can assume the fight takes place in the entity’s realm and not Freddie’s realm so Freddy is just a middle aged man with a knife glove and no longer immortal.

Freddy overpowered Jason in the real world and it turned out he is even here unkillable. Freddy is one of if not the last who would go down in a battle royal.

katoptris

@Hoodied said:

Pyramid Head, definitely him as bullets couldn’t stop him and in the near end of Silent Hill, you didn’t even kill the Pyramid Heads, they actually used their own weapons against themselves.

If anything, Michael and Pyramid Head will have a fun fight

That was silent hill 2 the game.

Hoodied

@katoptris said:

https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1459993#Comment_1459993

That was silent hill 2 the game.

Yeah....which is where our Pyramid Head is from