Sloppy butcher or gift of pain?
Ive seen both used a good bit since the update so i just thought id see peoples opinions.
Sloppy is obviously easier to get as all you need to do is m1. And can easily reapply it over and over infinitely (Except on nurse lol) and doesn't rely on hooks to be nearby (scourge hooks in a nutshell)
But gift of pain comes with slowdown and if your already running perks that rely on hooks you can complete multiple perks at once. (For instance pain res, no way out, gift of pain)
So just thought id see. Thanks!
Comments
Well... for Killers like Nurse whom can't get many M1 hits GOP is better
But M1 Killers Sloppy is better
Then again if we are comparing these 2 perks then
Sloppy only slows down healing while GOP applies Gen slowdown to Survivors that heal
Yeah but on the reverse case you can apply sloppy then move onto the next survivor. And GOP requires scourge hooks. So i feel comparing them both have their advantages. But yeah i see the first part.
For me it depends on the killer and the other perks I’m using. I like GoP on instadown killers like Bubba (because then they have the debuff until they’re downed instead of being able to get injured and lose it) or if I’m already running Agi and/or other scourge hooks.
Otherwise for m1 killers I’ll usually just use Sloppy.
Depends on the killer for me. If i use mainly M1s Sloppy, consistency is king for me.
If i don't use M1s to much gift of Pain is a nice perk, but i don't usually go for it.
yeah ive been playin it on billy since this comment and its pretty good. thanks for the advice.
I've actually used GoP on Plague.
An odd choice, but the logic is if they stay sick then it makes no difference besides maybe the extra bleeding from Hemorrhage. If they cleanse, they get smacked by slowdown. To be it just increases he catch-22 nature of Plague nicely.
Sloppy slows down healing, but doesn't incentivise people to stay injured, and in fact can do the opposite because healing now takes too long to do over and over again.
Gift of Pain punishes healing further, making it take longer and then once healed they're stuck with an 18% repair penalty.
GOP is therefore better for stealthier killers who aren't afraid to also chase and hook, because the more they don't heal the more effective your free first hits are. On the contrary, for a more hit n run/slugging playstyle, Sloppy is better because it doesn't need you to hook them first.
Not to mention any M2 killer would instantly prefer GOP to Sloppy
Sloppy probaly better for killers that m1 alot and can maybe interrupt heals some way.
Gift of pain seems good on someone like oni maybe, if they heal they get slowdown and if they dont easier power all game.