Forced Penance buff
Keep the 80 seconds of Broken, even though it's weak AF and its only purpose is to hinder the protect & heal spam from Medkits / Circle of Healing / Mettle of Man.
Add the following effects:
Survivors who take Protection Hits suffer from the Incapactitated effect for 10 seconds. Once the Exit Gates are powered, Survivors who take Protection Hits are put into the dying state.
Comments
80 seconds of broken is actually considerable, it’s just that protection hits are too niche of a thing. Maybe Forced Penance could just always apply the broken status every time a healthy survivor becomes injured by any means. You’d probably need to reduce the timer to something like 30-45 seconds though. Just a thought.
The 10s of incapacitated means that survivors cannot tank a hit while the killer's carrying and use the speed boost to get to the hook and sabotage it before the killer gets there.