Rank the common perks
Survivor:
- Kindred
- Spine Chill
- We’ll Make It
- Resilience
- Small Game
- Plunderer’s Instinct
- Deja Vu
- Hope
- Dark Sense
- Premonition
- Slippery Meat
- Lightweight
- No One Left Behind
- This Is Not Happening
lol those bottom 5 are trash
Killer:
- Sloppy Butcher
- Hex: No One Escapes Death
- Whispers
- Bitter Murmur
- Deerstalker
- Hex: Thrill of the Hunt
- Spies From The Shadows
- Distressing lol
- Unrelenting
- Iron Grasp
- Insidious
- Monstrous Shrine
Killers prob have even worse common perks, at least survivor has 4 really solid ones
Comments
I'd personally put This Is Not Happening over No One Left Behind simply because TINH might give you the occasional great skill check where NOLB is completely useless in the current meta - players don't open gates unless all survivors are accounted for or when they're about to bail because the killer is chasing them out, and neither scenario allows for final hour saves and other altruism.
It's pretty sad when a killer perk that only hurts you and is worse than useless by itself is only 5th worst, but I can't actually argue with your placement of it.
I think We'll Make It is better than Spine Chill, and hyper heals are generally better than a failsafe substitute for situational awareness, but your top 5 survivor perks are all really good and individual ranking is going to come down to personal preference (and solo vs swf.)