Are Nurse, Spirit, and Hag M1s or M2s?

Personally I think they are M1s but what do you think?

Comments

  • Their power itself doesn't hurt people, so technically they're M1 killers.

  • M1 is often used to refer to Killers that, after exiting their power, cannot do anything but walk at a Survivor and M1. All 3 of these Killers use their powers a lot during chase, so therefore I believe they are M2 Killers.

  • Well if you mean the attack itself, it's technically an M1 attack since all of them apply Sloppy. But if you mean like "M1 Killer" in a chase then no, cause that means they have no power in a chase while Nurse and Spirit use their powers constantly in chases and most Hags don't even commit to chases. Other than Ghostface and Pig, most killers are only situationally considered "M1 Killers". Like Oni before he gets his power, Billy after he heats up, Legion/Plague after the survivor is already injured, Blight in round loops etc etc.

  • All of their attacks count as basic attacks they are m1 killers

  • @WishIcouldmain said:

    Personally I think they are M1s but what do you think?

    Not M1 killers at all. I mean they use the m1 but their power exists, and a lot! If you've played this game a bit more you should know the difference

  • @bjorksnas said:

    All of their attacks count as basic attacks they are m1 killers

    No one would say, while describing these 3 Killers, "they are an M1 Killer". That's comparing Wraith and Legion to Nurse and Spirit, YOU CAN'T.

    They can't inflict damage with their M2s, but that's not the qualification most people use.

  • An M1 killer is a killer that chases as normal, Nurse & Spirit chase with their powers, and Hag doesn't chase to begin with

  • @Critical_Fish said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1902522#Comment_1902522

    No one would say, while describing these 3 Killers, "they are an M1 Killer". That's comparing Wraith and Legion to Nurse and Spirit, YOU CAN'T.

    They can't inflict damage with their M2s, but that's not the qualification most people use.

    Wraith, Spirit, Nurse, Hag

    All 4 of these killers attacks activate basic attack perks

    Sloppy Butcher, Save the best for last (except nurse because blink fatigue overtakes weapon wipe), Surge

    They physically can't do a special attack that operates outside of these perks

    For example demo saving stacks with shred, spirit can't save stacks with phase walk

  • Their powers don't really do anything to injure the survivors, They just use their powers to catch up to the survivors to m1 them.

  • @bjorksnas said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1903084#Comment_1903084

    Wraith, Spirit, Nurse, Hag

    All 4 of these killers attacks activate basic attack perks

    Sloppy Butcher, Save the best for last (except nurse because blink fatigue overtakes weapon wipe), Surge

    They physically can't do a special attack that operates outside of these perks

    For example demo saving stacks with shred, spirit can't save stacks with phase walk

    You don't define Spirit or Nurse as an M1 Killer because they use their powers proactively in the chase. If a Killer cannot use their power in the chase, they are an M1 Killer.

  • @Critical_Fish said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1903792#Comment_1903792

    You don't define Spirit or Nurse as an M1 Killer because they use their powers proactively in the chase. If a Killer cannot use their power in the chase, they are an M1 Killer.

    Thats what im currently doing though

    Differences

    Nurse uses m2 in a chase then hits an m1 basic attack post blink

    Blight uses m2 in a chase then hits a lethal rush which doesn't count as a basic attack

    My list for are they an m1 killer

    Does their power count as an alternative attack that can down survivors (this makes them not m1) Example Blight, Oni, Bubba

    Does their power count as a basic attack and can down survivors (this makes them m1) Example Nurse, Spirit, Hag

    Does their power not down survivor so they are forced to use basic attacks (this makes them m1) Example Legion, Vile Purge, Myers

  • @bjorksnas said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1903812#Comment_1903812

    Thats what im currently doing though

    Differences

    Nurse uses m2 in a chase then hits an m1 basic attack post blink

    Blight uses m2 in a chase then hits a lethal rush which doesn't count as a basic attack

    My list for are they an m1 killer

    Does their power count as an alternative attack that can down survivors (this makes them not m1) Example Blight, Oni, Bubba

    Does their power count as a basic attack and can down survivors (this makes them m1) Example Nurse, Spirit, Hag

    Does their power not down survivor so they are forced to use basic attacks (this makes them m1) Example Legion, Vile Purge, Myers

    So we're using two different metrics here.

    I'd only consider the third group there m1 Killers.

  • @Critical_Fish said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/1903976#Comment_1903976

    So we're using two different metrics here.

    I'd only consider the third group there m1 Killers.

    yes

  • M1 killers are killers that don’t rely on their power for downs, their powers are just supplementary. M2 killers are forced to use their power to down people, it isn’t just supplementary. IE they are m2 killers.