Does pgtw/overcharge/hex ruin stack?

When you have pgtw and kick a gen while having overcharge,will it go down by 25% and have the overcharge stack? Also does the failing skillcheck penalty from overcharge stack with the hex ruin passive?

Tagged: Trusted

Comments

  • PGTW does stack with Overcharge but the penalty from missing the Overcharge skill check will remain the same.

    @FireHazard if I got anything incorrect I'm tagging you because you're the god of this sub section ๐Ÿ˜…

  • @Boosted_Dwight said:

    PGTW does stack with Overcharge but the penalty from missing the Overcharge skill check will remain the same.

    @FireHazard if I got anything incorrect I'm tagging you because you're the god of this sub section ๐Ÿ˜…

    I am? ๐Ÿ˜€

    Anyways, you're indeed right!!! But you don't need me to approve it of course. Don't doubt yourself my friend!

    @CLAUDETTEINABUSH

    The Overcharge skillcheck is in its own class of skillchecks. Meaning it isn't affected by Ruins regression penalty since its not considered a Great or Good skillcheck, it's sort of a special skillcheck of its own.

    Failing Overcharge would cause it to explode... which doesn't work with Ruins passive ability anyways since the regression happens from only Good skillchecks. Failing a Skillcheck on ruin would just give a normal regression penalty, even if Ruin is active or not.

    So no, failing a Skillcheck with overcharge and Ruin would still only cause an additional 5% regression, not 10% since failing a skillcheck with Ruin doesn't add more regression anyways... its only when you hit Good skillchecks and NOT fail them.

  • @FireHazard said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/952367#Comment_952367

    I am? ๐Ÿ˜€

    Anyways, you're indeed right!!! But you don't need me to approve it of course. Don't doubt yourself my friend!

    @CLAUDETTEINABUSH

    The Overcharge skillcheck is in its own class of skillchecks. Meaning it isn't affected by Ruins regression penalty since its not considered a Great or Good skillcheck, it's sort of a special skillcheck of its own.

    Failing Overcharge would cause it to explode... which doesn't work with Ruins passive ability anyways since the regression happens from only Good skillchecks. Failing a Skillcheck on ruin would just give a normal regression penalty, even if Ruin is active or not.

    So no, failing a Skillcheck with overcharge and Ruin would still only cause an additional 5% regression, not 10% since failing a skillcheck with Ruin doesn't add more regression anyways... its only when you hit Good skillchecks and NOT fail them.

    Thanks guys. I appreciate it.

    @Boosted_Dwight said:

    PGTW does stack with Overcharge but the penalty from missing the Overcharge skill check will remain the same.

    @FireHazard if I got anything incorrect I'm tagging you because you're the god of this sub section ๐Ÿ˜…


  • @FireHazard said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/952367#Comment_952367

    I am? ๐Ÿ˜€

    Anyways, you're indeed right!!! But you don't need me to approve it of course. Don't doubt yourself my friend!

    @CLAUDETTEINABUSH

    The Overcharge skillcheck is in its own class of skillchecks. Meaning it isn't affected by Ruins regression penalty since its not considered a Great or Good skillcheck, it's sort of a special skillcheck of its own.

    Failing Overcharge would cause it to explode... which doesn't work with Ruins passive ability anyways since the regression happens from only Good skillchecks. Failing a Skillcheck on ruin would just give a normal regression penalty, even if Ruin is active or not.

    So no, failing a Skillcheck with overcharge and Ruin would still only cause an additional 5% regression, not 10% since failing a skillcheck with Ruin doesn't add more regression anyways... its only when you hit Good skillchecks and NOT fail them.

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but Overcharge DOES stack with Huntress: Lullaby on the regression penalty, correct? Since Lullaby's extra regression comes with a failed skillcheck as opposed to a good or great one. Making that the way to make Overcharge even more threatening, iirc.

  • No problemo!

    @LordRegal said:

    https://forum.deadbydaylight.com/en/discussion/comment/952461#Comment_952461

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but Overcharge DOES stack with Huntress: Lullaby on the regression penalty, correct? Since Lullaby's extra regression comes with a failed skillcheck as opposed to a good or great one. Making that the way to make Overcharge even more threatening, iirc.

    It doesn't say anywhere that they do, but perks that don't have a "does not stack" warning below usually stack with other perks of the same nature.

    That's usually how it goes, perks like Self-Care and Botany Knowledge work together, same with other such perks as well. You can argue that a fully stacked Hex: Huntresses Lullaby with Overcharge is a very scary combo... since the notification for the skillcheck is removed at 5 stacks AND failing the skillcheck results in a 5% bonus regression from overcharge AND a 6% regression of failed skillchecks from Huntresses.

    Making that 11% if you fail the skillcheck... but some could argue that PGTW is still better than that combo... since it's a flat 25% regression RATHER THAN a penalty that works off of failed skillchecks.

    But someone like The Doctor would have a field day with it, so...